Enter your username:
Do you want to login or register?
  • Forgot your password?

    Login / Register




    Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 1 2 3 LastLast
    Results 21 to 40 of 44
    1. #21
      Join Date
      Feb 2006
      Location
      South West... Viva la New Mexico!
      Posts
      50
      first off man, truck arm suspensions are gay. I am sick of hearing NASCAR this and NASCAR that! the onlt reason they are still in nascar is beacuse it is an easy suspension to manipulate they cars only turn one direction and the morons that make up the "sanctioning body" of NASCAR arent smart enough to figure out how to regulate any other type of suspension..... doubt me? let me know when an F car shows up with one and I will shut up.... Now dont get me wrong, are they geometrically hateful? absolutely not and they can and do work well but are they anything comperable to a well engineered link system? the answer is no they are not. And Mean69 I think what you are talking about is back halfing the car which has been around for a while and I dont think it is anything new.



    2. #22
      Join Date
      Nov 2003
      Location
      Paradise, Ca
      Posts
      1,411
      Quote Originally Posted by DonQuehotey
      And Mean69 I think what you are talking about is back halfing the car which has been around for a while and I dont think it is anything new.
      First of all, back halving requires new frame rails. We're using the stock frame rails.

      Second, from this thread:

      Quote Originally Posted by Mean69
      We didn't invent the three link, nor the Watt's linkage, we merely chose this as a basis for solving an engineering problem that we were faced with, and further adapating it to a very specific set of product requirements.
      -Matt

      Welders: The only people that think a co-worker catching on fire is funny.

    3. #23
      Join Date
      Feb 2006
      Location
      SoCal
      Posts
      1,622

      And the heat goes on.....

      Hmmmmm......seems like from what I am hearing, for pro-tour setups, generally, an IRS or 3 link seems to be the trick. Anyone wanna comment on that?

    4. #24
      Join Date
      Aug 2004
      Posts
      957
      Hmmmmm......seems like from what I am hearing, for pro-tour setups, generally, an IRS or 3 link seems to be the trick. Anyone wanna comment on that?
      You will certainly get many different opinions on this question. We obviously have our own opinions, based upon physical facts, and there are others that have theirs too. I have said it a million times, with ANY suspension system, you HAVE to choose the areas that you will compromise on, the two main areas that battle for the early muscle cars are packaging, and performance. If you work within the physical envelope of the existing floor and trunk pan, frame rails, etc, without cutting the car to make room, there is only so much you can do. If you go outside those bounds by making room where necessary to allow the design to address compromises of the previous approach, you can push the available performance envelope (of course, only if you understand what you are doing).

      There's a great article in PHR's latest issue (I haven't gotten mine, but I have heard from others that they are now being delivered) that explains the various types of suspension systems. It only scratches the surface of the true technical details, and keep in mind also that there is always bias from contributors (including me), but it is a terrific primer for sorting out all of the various design approaches currently available. Steve did a great job on it in my opinion. Grab a copy, it's worth it.

      Mark

    5. #25
      Quote Originally Posted by Mean 69
      Our approach is to put performance ahead of everything else, including being able to bolt the kit on
      Quote Originally Posted by Mean 69
      If you work within the physical envelope of the existing floor and trunk pan, frame rails, etc, without cutting the car to make room, there is only so much you can do. If you go outside those bounds by making room where necessary to allow the design to address compromises of the previous approach, you can push the available performance envelope (of course, only if you understand what you are doing).
      Mark,

      I have read a few of your posts (searched for a few as well), and over and over you make the claim that your suspension makes no compromises and is focused toward performance only. You further allude that it will outperform any suspension system that stays within the confines of the stock sheetmetal/frame envelope.

      Is this what you are trying to state?

      If so, be careful or at least add some tech to support your position. On paper things may look good, how that translates to the end user is sometimes a different story.

      Thanks…Mike
      Last edited by derekf; 02-15-2006 at 10:43 AM. Reason: Appears to have been a font glitch.

    6. #26
      Join Date
      Aug 2004
      Posts
      17

      Evolution Motorsports

      Mike,

      What are your thoughts on a rear suspension set-up for older muscle cars. Obviously I'm interested in something for a '66 Nova. What do you recomend for a car that will be a daily driver, see some track time, and not require back-halving a car?

      -j

    7. #27
      Join Date
      Oct 2003
      Location
      Arvada, Co
      Posts
      2,119
      Country Flag: United States
      Quote Originally Posted by EvolutionMotorsport
      Mark,



      I have read a few of your posts (searched for a few as well), and over and over you make the claim that your suspension makes no compromises and is focused toward performance only. You further allude that it will outperform any suspension system that stays within the confines of the stock sheetmetal/frame envelope.



      Is this what you are trying to state?



      If so, be careful or at least add some tech to support your position. On paper things may look good, how that translates to the end user is sometimes a different story.



      Thanks…Mike



      Mike,

      I am trying to understand where you are coming from here. Your first sentance does not support the quote you had of Marks. He clearly states that his design compromise was working within the stock envolope and designing the best geometry within those confines.

      He has supported his position many times here. He has added as much tech about his design as he saw fit. You would not give your design specs out freely. Why would you expect Mark to?

      I would assume you saw his three link at SEMA. You can see it is a well thought out design. It has been improved upon since then. A little marketplace competition go along way in providing the best product for the consumer. If you feel threatend by Marks design then design something you feel is better and market it. Until then your attacking of Mark seems immature.

      Just give your side of the story and let the consumer figure out what they want.
      Brian


      I have an unlimited budget. That bad part is I have already used it up.

    8. #28
      What are your thoughts on a rear suspension set-up for older muscle cars. Obviously I'm interested in something for a '66 Nova. What do you recomend for a car that will be a daily driver, see some track time, and not require back-halving a car?




      J-



      We currently have a frame mounted Watts/TriLink system for the late model Mustangs. The system is a bolt in system that only requires a few drilled holes and hand tools. We are in the process of porting that design to the older Ford – GM – Mopar (in that order) vehicles. It should move over nicely, since the late model Mustangs are little more constrained for space. So, our area will be the Watts/TriLink System that can be bolted in without losing your floor or trunk…..





      Quote Originally Posted by baz67
      Mike,
      Quote Originally Posted by baz67



      I am trying to understand where you are coming from here. Your first sentance does not support the quote you had of Marks. He clearly states that his design compromise was working within the stock envolope and designing the best geometry within those confines.




      Huh? He is not working within the stock envelope, unless I am mistaken.




      I would assume you saw his three link at SEMA. You can see it is a well thought out design. It has been improved upon since then. A little marketplace competition go along way in providing the best product for the consumer.




      Nope. Didn't go to SEMA this year. Not really concerned about the design. We have our own.



      You would not give your design specs out freely.




      What design specs did I ask for? What specs do you want? We ran the gauntlet at Corner Carvers years ago and freely disseminated information. I do not know what design specs you are thinking of, but most of them are not super secret information. Do want the gauge of metal, link lengths, tubing sizes, material properties…None of this information will compromise a design….



      If you feel threatend by Marks design then design something you feel is better and market it. Until then your attacking of Mark seems immature.




      Not threatened at all. We won a SEMA award for our frame mounted Watts link 3 1/2 years ago, and developed the TriLink for the Mustangs last year. Industry firsts from a commercially available standpoint, if I am not mistaken. Porting our design to other platforms is natural progression. 12 years of vehicle dynamics development helps too…



      As far as attacking. Your sensitivity may be a bit heightened. I cautioned about making subjective statements. This is what he posted earlier:



      A foreword on these kits, none of them will be bolt in. We have looked long and hard at the compromises associated with the bolt in approach, and there just is not enough room to make the links long enough to afford the performance we are after. Technically, the late model Mustang ('05's) are three link suspensions, but the control arms (upper one being the most challenging to package) are so damn short that the geometry is pure crap (in our not so humble opinion) dynamically, which is where it counts on the race course, or in a spirited street environment. Others will most likely hop on the three link bandwagon for Pro Touring cars, but I can tell you that their approach(es) will not likely be the same as ours, and that's okay. Our approach is to put performance ahead of everything else, including being able to bolt the kit on (which is not to say that the install is overly complex either, it's not).




      I am thinking this was somehow directed toward us. Basically it says, if you stick within the confines of the vehicle structure you will end up with a pure crap suspension and suffer performance gains. To get maximum performance (better than the crappy new Mustang), you need to invest in a system that did not have the limitation of the stock vehicle structure.



      All I am saying is what will suffer? Why is the new Mustang pure crap? Did a book say that, or did someone test it. Products should be measured on their technical merit, not marketing buzz words.



      As for jumping on the bandwagon, I do not think that is the case either.



      Just give your side of the story and let the consumer figure out what they want.




      Our side of the story. In the nutshell, we are developing a full tunable rear suspension system that will utilize a Frame Mounted Watts Link and a Three Link, without compromising the factory structure of the vehicle.



      Thanks…Mike

    9. #29
      Join Date
      Oct 2004
      Location
      Indiana
      Posts
      221
      .@all that jack away on the rear

    10. #30
      Join Date
      Oct 2004
      Location
      Indiana
      Posts
      221
      Mike
      one question for ya man. I know the benifits of a watts link are too eliminate any and all lateral movement of the rear within the chassis but is it really that much more benificial over a properly set up pan hard bar? I have played with some watts link designs and I am just curious on your take on it.

    11. #31
      Join Date
      Oct 2004
      Location
      Indiana
      Posts
      221
      what happend to my post up above? I went to edit and add some stuff and it is MIA.

    12. #32
      Quote Originally Posted by Tony@AirRideTech
      what happend to my post up above? I went to edit and add some stuff and it is MIA.
      Hey what did happen to your post....That was a nice post to boot...

      As for your Watts/Panhard question.
      • Watts Link System travels through true vertical motion through full vehicle suspension displacement. A Panhard bar suspension travels on an arc defined by the length of the bar.
      • Rear roll center height is constant while cornering. Panhard bar rear roll center height will rise in one vehicle turning direction and fall in the opposite turning direction.
      They are the main differences...

      Mike

    13. #33
      Join Date
      Nov 2004
      Location
      NW Arkansas
      Posts
      1,742
      Quote Originally Posted by Tony@AirRideTech
      .@all that jack away on the rear

      It was a good post.....maybe you got edited
      KENNY DAVIS HOTRODS

    14. #34
      Join Date
      Oct 2004
      Location
      Indiana
      Posts
      221
      nope damnit....... I am sure that was my clumsy freakin fingers while I was trying to add to it

      Mike, I understand that and I do get it, I am only trying to determine if the variable is that dynamic when comparing to a descent length panhard bar and a street suspension that averages 3-3.5" of compression stroke. I am not doubting you or calling you out by any means, I only wanted to hear your theory and yes I do see what you are getting at....

    15. #35
      Join Date
      Aug 2004
      Posts
      957
      Rear roll center height is constant while cornering.
      Sure about that?

      I apologize if folks feel my posts were inappropriate, we worked very hard on our designs, and feel very strongly that they are solid from a design, execution, and performance standpoint. This seems to be turning into a wee-wee contest, and that is usually not good for anyone. Once EVM, or any of the other companies (yes, Mike, you are not alone, there are others out there too) looking to solve a handling problem with a three link, and not moving forward into the trunk/interior area, well, we can compare products at that point. I'm sorry, but there just is extremely little room above the axle assembly, and directly in front of it, the upper link would have to be really, really short, and in that case, there is a very limited amount of things you can do to the geometry. Freeing up that real estate, slightly, offers a significant opportunity to really nail the geometry. We wish it weren't so, it'd make life a lot easier, but this is main limiting factor.

      Tony, there are two approaches to a Watt's linkage, in general. As Mike pointed out above, the roll center being fixed as a function of suspension travel is one of them, but only in the specific case where the bellcrank (the central pivot point, which specifically defines the roll center) is fixed to the axle, NOT the frame. In this case, the roll center height is fixed, but what is more important to a handling situation is not the roll center, but the roll MOMENT. The roll moment is the distance between the roll center (again, defined by the Bellcrank), and the COG of the sprung mass, basically at the rear end of the car (not specifically, but close enough for argument's purpose). In the case where the Bellcrank is mounted to the axle, and the Roll Center Height is fixed (so long as the axle is in contact with the road, that is), then the roll moment will change because the sprung mass COG will change as a function of suspension droop/bump.

      In the case of a frame mounted Watt's, like our setup, the EVM Mustang setup and undoubtedly their derivitives for other cars, FAYS2, and many others, the roll center height CHANGES as a function of COG motion (i.e. bump and droop), in fact it changes the exact same amount as the amount of suspension travel. But, the important aspect is that the roll MOMENT is NOT changing, which is a good thing. This subtle difference is important because the amount of roll a car will experience for a given lateral load depends upon the roll moment, NOT the roll center height (though the moment is calculated from the roll center height), so if it is fixed relative to suspension travel, then the stabilizer bars, springs, etc will see a stable force in roll, independent of suspension droop and bump.

      By comparison, the PHB roll center height (and therefore the roll moment) migrate at distance of 1/2 the suspension travel (and in the same direction), if the bar is mounted centrally to the car, and it is suitably long.

      In practice, all can work terrific, and the choice of one over others is dependent upon the intent of the vehicle, suspension travel, COG height, packaging constraints, etc. We chose the approach we took because it offered an incremental improvement over the other approaches, it was easy to package, and offered a slight reduction in sprung weight. And again, we didn't invent it, we didn't steal it, this design has been used for decades on cars and many other mechanical applications, it is a convenient solution to an engineering problem.

      Huh? He is not working within the stock envelope, unless I am mistaken.
      Mike, please re-read Brian's comment, the design COMPROMISE that we made was NOT working within the stock floorpan envelope. We compromised the floor, slightly, in order to fit the performance in (just like DSE has with their Quad Link and their terrific SFC's, HTH in certain applications, everyone that has mini-tubbed a car, and on and on).

      Mark-out

    16. #36
      Join Date
      Jul 2003
      Location
      Anaheim Hills, CA
      Posts
      11,967
      Country Flag: United States
      Quote Originally Posted by Travis B
      It was a good post.....maybe you got edited
      If a moderator edits a post it will say who it was and when it was done at the bottom of the post.. we are innocent
      "A ship in port is safe, but that's not what ships are built for."

      1968 Track Rat Camaro:
      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SGHJ5c1yLIo&t=2s

      1971 Chevelle Wagon with a few mods:
      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WBVPR3sRgyU

    17. #37
      Join Date
      Mar 2005
      Location
      westchester county new york
      Posts
      2,995
      Don, you say the truckarm design is "gay".

      I am new to suspension design and theory, how can I tell if my rear suspension is "gay"? Will I sense it? Will it just appear too neat, or rust to a pinkish color? Will it shy away from the track and prefer shows?

    18. #38
      Join Date
      Jul 2005
      Location
      Mountain View, CA
      Posts
      9,583
      Country Flag: United States
      Quote Originally Posted by Steve1968LS2
      If a moderator edits a post it will say who it was and when it was done at the bottom of the post.. we are innocent

      Unless a mod completely deletes a post.

      You know what I'm talkin 'bout mister
      True T.

      Whats new with Project 1/2-Trak?


      Follow my wisecracks on Sports, Food, Politics and other BS on Twitter.

      My blog

      When they kick out your front door, How you gonna come?
      With your hands on your head, Or on the trigger of your gun?

    19. #39
      Quote Originally Posted by Tony@AirRideTech
      nope damnit....... I am sure that was my clumsy freakin fingers while I was trying to add to it

      Mike, I understand that and I do get it, I am only trying to determine if the variable is that dynamic when comparing to a descent length panhard bar and a street suspension that averages 3-3.5" of compression stroke. I am not doubting you or calling you out by any means, I only wanted to hear your theory and yes I do see what you are getting at....
      Tony,


      Bottom line with our watts vs the panhard…On standard street duty the average driver may not notice a great difference. Then again the average driver probably isn’t making this upgrade. With the rear roll couple remaining constant through suspension travel and the fact that the rear roll center does not rise and fall due to the direction of cornering the car will be much easier to tune, which will result in a more consistent and dynamic response in transient and steady state maneuvers.

      The big plus here is the minimized tuning you would need for the “curvies”…With a PHB you are tuning for two directions and ultimately making compromises. In an auto-X or road course environment, you will notice the difference.

      Everyone,


      From a general product development standpoint, we would like to let everyone know that we are coming from a vehicle dynamics background in the automotive industry. We have all that heavy duty math and engineering, but it’s experience that drives our designs. We have spent countless hours at the proving grounds tuning more suspensions than most people see in their lifetime. This affords us the time and ability to make good suspensions better and bad suspensions work. A lot of people fall into the theory trap. Equations and theory are nice places to start, but ultimately theory trails off and real world functionality takes over.

      We just want people to start letting common sense enter into their decisions at some point. We once talked to a guy that kept harping on the fact that our system was 1 pound heavier (sprung weight) than another system. He had great concerns over the added weight. We asked if he could tell the difference in handling characteristics of his car with a can of Coke in the trunk. He couldn’t.

      We have no desire to start a “wee wee” contest. All we wanted to do is keep the subjective statements to a minimum. When our product hits the market we will post it and support the design. Until then we can only fall back on our current designs.

      I think Tony said it best. I will paraphrase….In 95% of the cases, the suspension will not be the limiting factor. Most likely it will be the driver. People will ultimately go with their gut. The nature of the beast is there are those that are not satisfied unless they are cutting and welding and there are those that have no desire to do so. That does not mean one suspension design is better than the next. It just means some people like to cut, some people choose not too.

      We will worry about comparing designs when there are designs to compare.

      Thanks…Mike

    20. #40
      Join Date
      Aug 2004
      Location
      Red Deer, Alberta, Canada
      Posts
      1,364
      Country Flag: Canada
      Nevermind, works in Windows Explorer, Not Slimbrowser.

      -Matt
      Matt
      72 Chevelle 370ci, 76mm single turbo, TKX, Speedtech Track Time, Millerbuilt Strange full floater 9", Brembo brakes, BC Forged 18x11s with 315s square
      Instagram: Cst_koon

    Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 1 2 3 LastLast



    Advertise on Pro-Touring.com