Enter your username:
Do you want to login or register?
  • Forgot your password?

    Login / Register




    Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 1 2 3 LastLast
    Results 21 to 40 of 50
    1. #21
      Join Date
      Mar 2008
      Location
      Nashville, TN
      Posts
      142
      Country Flag: United States
      I agree... if you are looking for 650+ hp for a better price, you cant go wrong with BBC. If I was looking for 500-600 hp, then yeah I would probably consider an LSx setup.
      - Matt -
      '69 Camaro


    2. #22
      Join Date
      Mar 2010
      Location
      West Tennessee
      Posts
      124
      Country Flag: United States
      After MUCH deliberation and research, I've decided to go with a LS engine. I'm buying a 2004 GTO LS1 and T56 6-speed from Travis, one of our members here at PT.com. Future plans for the motor include a more aggressive cam swap, headers, and computer tune-up. I'm really hoping for a little over 500 HP when it's all said and done!

    3. #23
      Join Date
      Aug 2008
      Location
      ocala fl
      Posts
      279
      Country Flag: Wales
      I like to be different but it depends on what you want the car to do if you want good gas mileage you need an ls motor. if you want pro touring handling and to be competitive you need ls motor. If you want that low muscle sound from the exhaust you need bb if you want to open the hood at a car show and that engine bay full of motor you need bb. To me big valve covers with 572 on them is just cool.

    4. #24
      Join Date
      Jun 2010
      Location
      Commerce MI
      Posts
      50
      I know this is an old thread but I have to throw my 2 cents in here. Everyone seems to forget about the cost involved in making a 1st Gen Camaro play well with a LS motor, especially a EFI one. Your talking a bunch more money (Fuel system, ECU, Wire harness, motor mounts, bell housing, new headers) than just an engine swap. Sure I can get a custom LS 416 built for around 11K and have 600+ Hp, but I can do that easily with a BBC and do not all the work and cost of making the thing fit and work. I am sure I am missing some things here, but my point is, lets not forget about the other cost involved than just the motor...

    5. #25
      Join Date
      Apr 2009
      Posts
      327
      I love this thread, I have been asked why we went with a bbc a thousand times, based upon opinion only I give the following reasons,
      Dual purpose track and strip application.
      Big HP for money
      No replacement for displacement if on the strip
      Simply said nothing sounds like a bbc with a huge cam at idle or 6500+ rpm
      I agree fully with the weight savings and the mpg you gain from LS.
      Personal preference go with what you want.

    6. #26
      Join Date
      Mar 2008
      Location
      austria, where the kangaroos go skiing
      Posts
      190
      Country Flag: Austria
      i just had 2 seasons with my all aluminum 540 street roller and iīm swapping to an 418cui LS just for one reason and thatīs just reliability. iīm definitely trading horsepower and tons of torque but the ease of turning the key and being able to drive thousands of miles without thinking once about oil pressure/temperature/roller lifters die and also oil leaking. i never had any of those issues except of small oil leaks and i made around 6000miles and i even never had to adjust the solid rollers but now iīm really looking forward to do the first test drives with the LS. i could let you know in a couple months about the whole thing cause iīm planning dyno tests to compare both engines handling and powerwise
      69 camaro, 418cui p1sc1, ridetech,forgeline, and some more money wasted

    7. #27
      Join Date
      Jun 2010
      Location
      Commerce MI
      Posts
      50
      Wow,,, that 540 must be bad ass.. Are you selling it?? I could not agree more with SDS.. Forget about what everyone else is doing. Do what you think is cool and within your means. If I had my choice I would as well go with a built LS, just not in the cards...Yet!!
      Let us know how your LS conversion goes. Good luck with your project.



    8. #28
      Join Date
      Jul 2012
      Location
      Traverse City, MI
      Posts
      574
      Country Flag: United States
      LS Engines can make insane amounts of horsepower with boost. For N/A? Sure there is no replacement for displacement.

      But before you go making crazy claims about Big Blocks making power for relatively low cost as compared to small LS motors please consider these articles -
      http://www.carcraft.com/techarticles...d/viewall.html
      http://www.superchevy.com/technical/...p/viewall.html
      http://www.hotrod.com/techarticles/e...2/viewall.html

      And if you want to argue reliability -
      http://www.hotrod.com/techarticles/h...g_bang_theory/

      Yes I agree you will lose the awesome grunt (torque) of a BBC and you wont have that window shattering rumble but SO? What do you gain though - Efficiency, reliability, commonality.

      Im over carbs and oil leaks. Fill my car with electronics.

      Completely unrelated - I have a 396 for sale
      Project thread - https://www.pro-touring.com/threads/...ouring-Project
      IG - @tc_chevelle


    9. #29
      Join Date
      Jun 2010
      Location
      Commerce MI
      Posts
      50
      Lets not forget the Labor to build these motors. These articles tend to leave that out. Yeah, you can get a used block cheap and source all the parts to build a high performance LS motor for a decent price, but unless your an experience engine builder with all the tools your adding another 2 to 3 grand minimum. As well as another 5k or more to make an LS fit and work in a 1st gen (if you can't do it yourself). Again, if I could do it myself I would in a heart beat. Agreed, better MPG, better reliability, no leaks, LS is the way to go. Just damn expensive if you do not have the ability to do it yourself, or of course get parts for free from your sponsors.

    10. #30
      Join Date
      Nov 2008
      Location
      Lawrenceburg, TN
      Posts
      4,098
      Country Flag: United States
      Quote Originally Posted by Glock 18;831155(4)
      And why are so many people going with LS engines these days?
      thats easy, I put in an LS engine and no longer have a single oil leak, and my old 383 got about 12 miles per gallon, the new engine with the same Carb, Transmission, and rear end gears that were used on the 383, now gives almost 20 miles per gallon(19.8) at 65 MPH and more torque

    11. #31
      Join Date
      Jul 2012
      Location
      Traverse City, MI
      Posts
      574
      Country Flag: United States
      Quote Originally Posted by Tom5410 View Post
      Lets not forget the Labor to build these motors. These articles tend to leave that out. Yeah, you can get a used block cheap and source all the parts to build a high performance LS motor for a decent price, but unless your an experience engine builder with all the tools your adding another 2 to 3 grand minimum. As well as another 5k or more to make an LS fit and work in a 1st gen (if you can't do it yourself). Again, if I could do it myself I would in a heart beat. Agreed, better MPG, better reliability, no leaks, LS is the way to go. Just damn expensive if you do not have the ability to do it yourself, or of course get parts for free from your sponsors.
      Agreed - but thats true for all engines. I can easily tune my truck engine via HP Tuners but I'll be the first to admit that Im scared to touch my quadrajet.
      Project thread - https://www.pro-touring.com/threads/...ouring-Project
      IG - @tc_chevelle


    12. #32
      Join Date
      Apr 2009
      Posts
      327
      this thread gets better every time i check in on it, I totally agree with LS is the way to go these days for total reliability and mpg when building a car to drive every day, weight savings etc... i view it in a manner similar to how the old school hot rod guys do that still use flat head motors, why do those guys use a flat head? (its looks and nostalgia) I know the answer its just something to think about why some guys go conventional motor in their muscle car vs LS. bottom line is its still personal preference and in regards to losing the window shaking thump of a big cam, IMO thats what makes a car unique, everyone cares what their car sounds like. The feeling you get from the rumble and low end torque of a Big Block is what makes it fun. once again its opinion only.

    13. #33
      Join Date
      Mar 2008
      Location
      austria, where the kangaroos go skiing
      Posts
      190
      Country Flag: Austria
      Quote Originally Posted by Tom5410 View Post
      Wow,,, that 540 must be bad ass.. Are you selling it??
      if you are talking about me, yep i would maybe/not/i donīt know if somebody could tell me that a 418LS would be way better than an aluminum 540 i would do, but this thread wonīt answer this question cause it canīt be answered. if i had the money i owned two 69 camaros one with a n/a or small procharger 540 and a second one with a twin turbo LS. so itīs always a personal decision and canīt be pinned on reliability or insane torque. from a technical standpoint nobody would ever argue that a bigblock would be better but thinking this way i had to throw my camaro onto the junk and just keep driving my 330XD BMW wagon
      69 camaro, 418cui p1sc1, ridetech,forgeline, and some more money wasted

    14. #34
      Join Date
      Feb 2013
      Posts
      3
      Country Flag: Canada
      This has been a good read. Going through this debate right now. It seems a question is how much driving i plan to do. I think my ride might be 5000 miles at year at most. Not worried about fuel consumption. And you can get efi big blocks so i assume that address the carb issue.

    15. #35
      Join Date
      Jul 2012
      Location
      Traverse City, MI
      Posts
      574
      Country Flag: United States
      I was shopping for performance heads for big blocks last night. Holy price. Im finding pretty hard to believe that an equivalent HP LS build wouldnt be MUCH cheaper.
      Project thread - https://www.pro-touring.com/threads/...ouring-Project
      IG - @tc_chevelle


    16. #36
      Join Date
      Mar 2010
      Location
      Okinawa, Japan
      Posts
      305
      Country Flag: United States
      Quote Originally Posted by Barrrf View Post
      I was shopping for performance heads for big blocks last night. Holy price. Im finding pretty hard to believe that an equivalent HP LS build wouldnt be MUCH cheaper.
      You need to look at the used market, lots of BBC used parts and complete engines for cheap. Here is one on our board that all you would have to do is a cam and piston change for a 600hp turnkey motor:
      https://www.pro-touring.com/showthre...C-Merlin-Heads
      81 Regal, impersonating a Grand National with a 488 Olds
      Build thread: https://www.pro-touring.com/showthre...ith-a-488-Olds

    17. #37
      Join Date
      Apr 2009
      Posts
      327
      Quote Originally Posted by Rickerbucks View Post
      This has been a good read. Going through this debate right now. It seems a question is how much driving i plan to do. I think my ride might be 5000 miles at year at most. Not worried about fuel consumption. And you can get efi big blocks so i assume that address the carb issue.
      I saw an episode of Gears a few moths back when they did an LS swap and they actually interviewed a representative from Holly and were promoting their new EFI system, he actually stated then in some applications a Carb is better then EFI, I thought this maybe to be a sales tactic as Holly does not want to kill their market share of it carb sales, but until recently if your running big Cube In you were pretty much stuck with a carb set up, but now several companies are competing for for the EFI market and big Cube In motors are not an issue,, and the price is reasonable as well,, Check this out... http://nyesautomotive.net/632_EFI_PUMP_GAS.html how can you go wrong with this option?

    18. #38
      Join Date
      Jun 2010
      Location
      Deployed
      Posts
      3,376
      Country Flag: United States
      Quote Originally Posted by SDS MACHINING View Post
      I saw an episode of Gears a few moths back when they did an LS swap and they actually interviewed a representative from Holly and were promoting their new EFI system, he actually stated then in some applications a Carb is better then EFI, I thought this maybe to be a sales tactic as Holly does not want to kill their market share of it carb sales, but until recently if your running big Cube In you were pretty much stuck with a carb set up, but now several companies are competing for for the EFI market and big Cube In motors are not an issue,, and the price is reasonable as well,, Check this out... http://nyesautomotive.net/632_EFI_PUMP_GAS.html how can you go wrong with this option?
      People do seem to forget about all the little things involved in an LS swap. I sure did and the dollars add up quick!. First and foremost; the LS engines do not make BBC power out of the box. The exception would probably be the LS7, but hell its 427 cubic inches!

      When I planned out my 496 BBC in 2008, I figured it would cost me $6K. I had forged internals, Vic Jr heads and a roller valve train. It would have easily made 500/500+ on the conservative side. No special fuel tank required, electric fans etc.

      My LS1 cost me $2600 which was brand new. 350hp...Not BBC power yet...I added
      $300 Cam
      $120 Pushrods
      $1500 CNC heads
      $200 SLP Pump and Chain
      $500 Headers
      $1000 FAST Intake
      $400 TB
      $100 MAF
      $500 Wiring Harness
      $200 Fuel Injectors
      $500 Tuning
      $1500 for Fuel Tank (AN OEM FI tank is not made for my car) Strange....a sec gen Camaro...Who would have figured

      That's ~$9,420 and I'm not even counting all the little special LS tools I had to buy.

      I ended up with a 520hp LS motor that doesn't sound or have the torque the BBC would. No doubt, the reason I did the swap was for FI, but I honestly feel if you are drag racing, a solid BBC motor is tough to beat for the dollar.

      Now I know the junk yard deals are out there, but I don't think that's an apple to apple comparison...You could easily pick up a used 600hp BBC on craigslist for a couple grand just as easily as you could pick up a 5.3 LS for $500. But if you do it right! With new parts, the LS will sink your ship if you are not prepared for it.
      1970 Camaro/DSE build


      Are you driver enough? Maybe....come on blue!
      https://www.pro-touring.com/threads/...71#post1147371

    19. #39
      Join Date
      Jan 2012
      Posts
      107
      Country Flag: Cambodia
      Im looking for engine options for a high hp track car and for the Tx mile. To join the 200 mph club in a 3000lb car, you need 800hp plus. BBC and FI LSX are the best options. Most FI LSX cars are going with an iron block or a high end erl/rhs block. Add the weight of cooling and the money for custom parts and the build gets heavy and expensive.

      Im leaning more towards a BBC. I will go for for efi and maybe even an aluminum block and still be $8k-$10k under an LSX FI build. I would also be 200lbs lighter if the BBC aluminum block option is selected. Im not totally sold on the idea yet, but am leaning in that direction. An rhs tall deck 502 NA might get there also, but is very expensive.

    20. #40
      Join Date
      Apr 2009
      Posts
      327
      Quote Originally Posted by uxojerry View Post
      Im looking for engine options for a high hp track car and for the Tx mile. To join the 200 mph club in a 3000lb car, you need 800hp plus. BBC and FI LSX are the best options. Most FI LSX cars are going with an iron block or a high end erl/rhs block. Add the weight of cooling and the money for custom parts and the build gets heavy and expensive.

      Im leaning more towards a BBC. I will go for for efi and maybe even an aluminum block and still be $8k-$10k under an LSX FI build. I would also be 200lbs lighter if the BBC aluminum block option is selected. Im not totally sold on the idea yet, but am leaning in that direction. An rhs tall deck 502 NA might get there also, but is very expensive.
      I would love to know what you decide on, and what you build,,

    Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 1 2 3 LastLast



    Advertise on Pro-Touring.com