Enter your username:
Do you want to login or register?
  • Forgot your password?

    Login / Register




    Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 1 2 3 LastLast
    Results 21 to 40 of 48
    1. #21
      Join Date
      Dec 2004
      Location
      HILLBILLY HOLLYWOOD, TENNESSEE!!!
      Posts
      2,044
      Quote Originally Posted by wmhjr View Post
      Stated value policies are often fine in the event of damage. They are also often a nightmare in the event of a theft. Because there is nothing left to evaluate actual value, you are at the total mercy of the insurance company with no legal recourse at that point. For that reason, I would never, ever consider a stated value policy for a valuable collector vehicle. As we all know, thefts are more and more common. I'm actually far more concerned about theft than of damage myself. In your case, since the vehicle was available to inspect, the appraiser could also see the likely initial condition of the vehicle as well. So, you had the best possible circumstances to "test" your insurance company. If somebody has a street legal vehicle that they use to get to events, or other than at a track where theft is far more likely, stated value has very obvious negative issues with it.

      Every policy and company can have issues, and every one can also have success stories. Just ask your insurance company exactly what happens, step by step, in the event of a non-recovered theft. At any point if there is a question about the payout, move on. In the case of stated value, there will always be a question. State Farm was under no legal obligation to pay out the "stated value".
      Not necesarily!

      Many stated value policies REQUIRE a yearly updated appraisal of the car. This requirment is incumbant on the car owner to complete not the insurance company. If you do not complete the yearly or whatever time frame updates to the appraisal as outlined in the policy you the policy owner have violated the terms of the policy. These appraisal updates will define the value of the car especially when theft is involved since the car is not available for inspection by the adjuster as you noted. I you the car owner does NOT update the appraisal as required then YES the insurance company can an probably will have their way with you. Again READ THE POLICY to understand your requirements as the purchaser of the policy and the insuror's responsibility to you the purchaser.

      Stated value policies are not a bad product at all and may fit the needs of many collector car owners. Many times Stated Value policies are more liberal with the use of the car and the number of miles that can be driven.

      You are correct in your statement that "State Farm was under no legal obligation to pay out the Stated Value of the policy" and your assertion that theft is a much greater area of loss than flood or other types of Act Of God damage in the collector car world is true. State Farm WAS OBLIGATED AND ARE OBLIGATED to pay the MARKET VALUE of the asset on the date and time of the loss as outlined in the policy. That market value in the case of my 510 was equal to the "Stated Value" of the policy as demonstrated by the updated appraisals provided by me as required by the terms of the policy and by the market research of the claims adjuster. You are right! State Farm may have paid LESS OR they may have had to pay MORE than the "Stated Value" listed in the policy! Again the market value on the date of loss determines the asset value when you have a Stated Value policy. The market can and does change throughout the year. That's why the required yearly appraisal updates I have to submit are SO IMPORTANT!!!
      Mike

      Remember, "Drive Fast, Turn Heads, Break Hearts!"

      www.musclecardeals.com

    2. #22
      Join Date
      Mar 2005
      Location
      Woodbine, MD
      Posts
      2,770
      Country Flag: United States
      great...........guess I need to call around.
      Douglas Lutes
      1988 Monte Carlo SS

      "Never race anything you can't afford to set on fire and push off a cliff."

    3. #23
      Join Date
      Aug 2004
      Posts
      227
      Great responses Mike. I now have a few more questions to ask the Insurance Agent. Thank You.

      Steve
      Steve L

    4. #24
      Join Date
      Aug 2008
      Location
      Pgh, PA
      Posts
      2,177
      Mike,
      I get your points but just don't agree with the logic. In a stated value policy, regardless of any previous or annual appraisal, they are simply not bound to any specific dollar amount. The term "market value" is the problem. It always changes, and is subject to the discretion of the carrier. I am simply not comfortable in giving that discretion away for no good reason. While not necessarily rock solid, "agreed value" provides far more security for the insured. You see, the carrier can easily argue that your car is with less following the annual appraisal. With agreed value, they cannot. Moreover, with agreed value, you the owner have control over the value, and it is your responsibility to keep up with the market.

      You are correct in that stated value policies may be more liberal in use, but that is simply because they can afford to be. If you need that liberal set of allowances, stated value may be easier for you to find. However, I can't see any other possible advantage for it. And way too critical of a downside.

      I like certainty. There is without any question far less with stated value and it's too much risk for me considering the lack of any resulting advantage for the typical collector. Your case is a bit unique to start with since your vehicle is not street legal to begin with.
      '66 GTO Vert Project "Red Ink", 462ci of stroked pontiac power, TKO600, SC&C Stg II+, Tubular lowers, Currectrac Rear suspension, Moser 12bolt w/Truetrack, Wilwood Master and discs all around, too much fun for words...

    5. #25
      Join Date
      Aug 2008
      Location
      Pgh, PA
      Posts
      2,177
      Btw, here's another analogy that hits close to home. If you bought a home just before the bubble burst and got a mortgage, you had an appraised value for that home that within weeks in many locations was drastically reduced. To apply collector car insurance terms to it, if the home burned down "stated value" insurance would pay up to the "new or lower" value regardless of any previous appraisal. Agreed value would pay the dollar amount initially agreed on. I'm not saying that's how homeowners actually works, but just illustrating a point.
      '66 GTO Vert Project "Red Ink", 462ci of stroked pontiac power, TKO600, SC&C Stg II+, Tubular lowers, Currectrac Rear suspension, Moser 12bolt w/Truetrack, Wilwood Master and discs all around, too much fun for words...

    6. #26
      Join Date
      Dec 2004
      Location
      HILLBILLY HOLLYWOOD, TENNESSEE!!!
      Posts
      2,044
      EXACTLY!!!

      The value of the asset on the date of the loss!
      Mike

      Remember, "Drive Fast, Turn Heads, Break Hearts!"

      www.musclecardeals.com

    7. #27
      Join Date
      Dec 2004
      Location
      HILLBILLY HOLLYWOOD, TENNESSEE!!!
      Posts
      2,044
      Quote Originally Posted by wmhjr View Post
      Mike,
      I get your points but just don't agree with the logic. In a stated value policy, regardless of any previous or annual appraisal, they are simply not bound to any specific dollar amount. The term "market value" is the problem. It always changes, and is subject to the discretion of the carrier. I am simply not comfortable in giving that discretion away for no good reason. While not necessarily rock solid, "agreed value" provides far more security for the insured. You see, the carrier can easily argue that your car is with less following the annual appraisal. With agreed value, they cannot. Moreover, with agreed value, you the owner have control over the value, and it is your responsibility to keep up with the market.

      You are correct in that stated value policies may be more liberal in use, but that is simply because they can afford to be. If you need that liberal set of allowances, stated value may be easier for you to find. However, I can't see any other possible advantage for it. And way too critical of a downside.

      I like certainty. There is without any question far less with stated value and it's too much risk for me considering the lack of any resulting advantage for the typical collector. Your case is a bit unique to start with since your vehicle is not street legal to begin with.
      Once again that is YOUR level of comfort that you choose when buying insurance and you only like Agreed Coverage insurance policies for your collector cars. That's why there is regualar car insurance, Stated Value car insurance and Agreed Value car insurance. Different policies for different buyer's and different coverages.

      All I am suggesting with any type of policy is that the buyer READ THE POLICY, UNDERSTAND THE TERMS AND LIMITATIONS OF THE POLICY & BUY COVERAGE TO MEET THEIR NEEDS.

      Most people buy insurance with doing ANY OF THE ABOVE. They just ask their friends and relatives from whom they purchase insurance.



      If I have made just one PT member pull out their insurance policy and READ THE POLICY we have both successfully illustrated our points and opinions!
      Mike

      Remember, "Drive Fast, Turn Heads, Break Hearts!"

      www.musclecardeals.com


    8. #28
      Join Date
      Aug 2008
      Location
      Pgh, PA
      Posts
      2,177
      Quote Originally Posted by vintageracer View Post
      EXACTLY!!!

      The value of the asset on the date of the loss!
      But Mike, the problem is that THEY always have discretion to set that value. That is exactly the problem. Why in the world would you allow them to have that discretion? It is completely in their interest to minimize that market assessment. They can compare your previously appraised but no longer available vehicle to all the other "similar" ones which may well be of lesser quality and/or condition. Legally you have almost no recourse. I just can't see any advantage of doing that unless you have no other choice whatsoever. What would that reason be?
      '66 GTO Vert Project "Red Ink", 462ci of stroked pontiac power, TKO600, SC&C Stg II+, Tubular lowers, Currectrac Rear suspension, Moser 12bolt w/Truetrack, Wilwood Master and discs all around, too much fun for words...

    9. #29
      Join Date
      Aug 2008
      Location
      Pgh, PA
      Posts
      2,177
      Quote Originally Posted by vintageracer View Post
      Once again that is YOUR level of comfort that you choose when buying insurance and only like Agreed Coverage. That's why there is regualar car insurance, Stated Value car insurance and Agreed Value car insurance. Different policies for different buyer's and different coverages.

      All I am suggesting with any type of policy is that the buyer READ THE POLICY, UNDERSTAND THE TERMS AND LIMITATIONS & BUY COVERAGE TO MEET THEIR NEEDS.

      Most people buy insurance with doing ANY OF THE ABOVE. If I have made just one PT member pull out their insurance policy and READ THE POLICY we have both illustrated out points and opinions!
      totally agree with that. I just happen to believe that the only reason there are stated value policies is to allow the conventional players to advertise that they play in the collector market. Jmho.
      '66 GTO Vert Project "Red Ink", 462ci of stroked pontiac power, TKO600, SC&C Stg II+, Tubular lowers, Currectrac Rear suspension, Moser 12bolt w/Truetrack, Wilwood Master and discs all around, too much fun for words...

    10. #30
      Join Date
      Nov 2006
      Location
      Washington, MO
      Posts
      2,363
      I can't image giving an insurance company the flexibility of a 'stated' (market) value. The true value is what a buyer will pay, and there's no way to determine that in the event of a claim. Appraisals are bogus too. Why not just appraise the car yourself based on what its worth to you or what you have in it?

      Agreed value is the only way IMO.

    11. #31
      Join Date
      Dec 2004
      Location
      HILLBILLY HOLLYWOOD, TENNESSEE!!!
      Posts
      2,044
      Quote Originally Posted by Tony_SS View Post
      I can't image giving an insurance company the flexibility of a 'stated' (market) value. .
      IF you own and insure ANY type of regular late model car/truck with your regular agent you are doing EXACTLY THAT!!! Giving the insurance company "flexibility" (your choice of terms) in establishing a value of the asset.

      So what's the difference if it's a collector car or regular daily driver car? The fact that you are passionately involved with the collector car and not the daily driver? The money you have in the collector car? Just the idea that collector cars are "supposed" to hold their value or go up in value?

      In both cases a market value can be established for an asset on the day of loss. There are LOT'S of industry accepted standards to establish a value and that is what they must pay. By industry accepted I mean the insurance industry, used car industry AND the collector car hobby/industry.

      What about all the people upside down in their late model driver who wreck/total the car and the car is worth LESS than they owe? Is that the insurance companies fault? I have to buy another car. How am I going to pay for it if I still owe on the other car I wrecked?

      The loss of a late model driver car in which the insured is upside down happens everyday and is FAR more life changing than the loss of a collector car. The differences between newer car policies and collector car policies are not that different. Fortunately with a collector car policy you can have the option of Agreed Value coverage if that is important to you. You don't have that option with later model car insurance but yet you still buy that type of policy anyway for your later model vehicles!

      WHY would you buy regular car insurance on your daily driver cars/trucks if Agreed Coverage is so important to you in other areas of insurance coverage such as collector cars? Seems like a flip/flop to me?
      Mike

      Remember, "Drive Fast, Turn Heads, Break Hearts!"

      www.musclecardeals.com

    12. #32
      Join Date
      Aug 2008
      Location
      Pgh, PA
      Posts
      2,177
      Mike, the answer is actually very simple.

      Because the insurance policies are available. Collector insurance is a specialty market for a variety of reasons that we don't need to rehash. The fact that the cars are NOT used for daily trans, that they are statistically taken far better care of, the fact that they are involved in less (by percentage) losses. Those very "restrictions" that the carriers place on us is what allows them to treat them differently than our daily drivers. There is typically nothing very proprietary about our DDs. Other than minor things like maybe wheels or audio, they are often exactly as driven off the showroom floor - so it's nothing other than mileage and condition that makes them at all "unique". Nobody, and I mean nobody of any sense, buys a DD as an investment or with any hope that they will even hold their value, much less appreciate.

      You seem to think that we're ripping off the carriers by using agreed value. Not so. They make plenty of money. If they didn't, then that would not be their operating model. Remember, it's those "true collector insurance carriers" that themselves promote the advantages of "agreed value". They, like us, understand that it really isn't effective to determine a "market value" of a potentially unique and/or proprietary vehicle on the date of loss, especially if the vehicle is no longer available. How would you feel if you owned a Ridler winning vehicle and that happened? Exactly how do you "market value" a vehicle like that and protect your investment - remembering that insurance is for exactly that. Protecting your investment. There is simply no reason to leave that amount of risk on the table when there are very reasonable alternatives IMHO.

      The point is that many here as well as elsewhere pour not only tons of money, but even more importantly tons of time and effort in building from the ground up a very special vehicle. Good insurance companies recognize that we often treat them far better than the norm, that we (hopefully) drive them more safely, are less likely to leave them parked in the lot of a major shopping mall where theft is frequent, and that as such we are a far lower risk. They reward us with the ability to decide up front what the "agreed value" of our cars are, and then pay a fair premium BASED ON THE AMOUNT INSURED, AND ON CERTAIN RESTRICTIONS. Like total mileage, not using it as a daily driver, having to own a true DD and separate insurance policy, having to be of a certain age, etc. These restrictions allow them to create a "risk pool" that statistically provides us a very reasonable rate, and them a profit. It is unreasonable to expect the same thing for a daily driver.

      I'm not in the business of supporting insurance companies, and I feel relatively certain that they have a profitable operating model in offering such insurance. It is all legal, ethical and above board. We often still insure them for far far less than our actual investments not even including time. I'm a true capitalist at heart. The customer and the business need to both have their needs met, and I see (for cars like ours) that the agreed value polices are beneficial to all of us.

      So the question is why, knowing this, should somebody take a chance on stated value? I'm just trying to understand the logic behind it. BTW, I'm not beating you up at all. I truly appreciate the dialogue. I'm just trying to understand why - other than just because. Exactly what is it about a stated value policy that makes it worth consideration if an agreed value policy is available at a similar cost? Keeping in mind that the only companies that offer such stated value collector policies are admittedly not even remotely in the collector business - it's just an aside from their "core" business, such as life, property, casualty, etc.
      '66 GTO Vert Project "Red Ink", 462ci of stroked pontiac power, TKO600, SC&C Stg II+, Tubular lowers, Currectrac Rear suspension, Moser 12bolt w/Truetrack, Wilwood Master and discs all around, too much fun for words...

    13. #33
      Join Date
      Dec 2004
      Location
      HILLBILLY HOLLYWOOD, TENNESSEE!!!
      Posts
      2,044
      I don't look at purchasing Stated Value (SV) insurance as taking a chance. That's the difference in our arguments. I look at a SV policy as buying the proper insurance coverage for the vehicle in question. I have numerous Agreed Value (AV) policies also. I have the SV policies on several collector cars because the AV policy will not properly cover the vehicle based upon my use/needs for that vehicle. The AV polices I have are on cars that fit the requirements of the policy. The point being is that I am properly insured on all the vehicles based upon use/need. I like to drive my cars and use any number of them on a daily basis for fun and errands. Several do not fall into that category and therefore the AV policy is just fine for those rides.

      The collector car AV business is HUGELY profitable. Why do you think premiums are so low? Because the payout for loss, cost of advertising, cost to administer the policy and the needed PROFIT on the policy is a LOT less than their paid loss's every year. Basically the collector car insuror's enjoy a highly profitable loss to premium ratio. That's why AV policies have been cheap for years and getting cheaper as time goes on!

      If you really look at who really underwrites the policies for the Collector Car insurance carriers you will find that Hagarety does not underwrite the policy. That's laid off through Chubb, Lloyds or any other large specialty insurance companies. That's the way the business runs. Those large companies that underwrite that Hagarety policy are much more familiar with specialty coverages since that's their business model. Sure, State Farm and all the other regular line companies could do the same but that's not their business model. That really is good for us car guys since the specialty collector car insurance business is such a small part of the overall auto insurance industry. If it did not work this way you could bet your butt that premiums would be MUCH higher for AV collector car policies!
      Mike

      Remember, "Drive Fast, Turn Heads, Break Hearts!"

      www.musclecardeals.com

    14. #34
      Join Date
      Nov 2006
      Location
      Washington, MO
      Posts
      2,363
      Quote Originally Posted by vintageracer View Post
      IF you own and insure ANY type of regular late model car/truck with your regular agent you are doing EXACTLY THAT!!! Giving the insurance company "flexibility" (your choice of terms) in establishing a value of the asset.

      So what's the difference if it's a collector car or regular daily driver car? The fact that you are passionately involved with the collector car and not the daily driver? The money you have in the collector car? Just the idea that collector cars are "supposed" to hold their value or go up in value?

      In both cases a market value can be established for an asset on the day of loss. There are LOT'S of industry accepted standards to establish a value and that is what they must pay. By industry accepted I mean the insurance industry, used car industry AND the collector car hobby/industry.

      What about all the people upside down in their late model driver who wreck/total the car and the car is worth LESS than they owe? Is that the insurance companies fault? I have to buy another car. How am I going to pay for it if I still owe on the other car I wrecked?

      The loss of a late model driver car in which the insured is upside down happens everyday and is FAR more life changing than the loss of a collector car. The differences between newer car policies and collector car policies are not that different. Fortunately with a collector car policy you can have the option of Agreed Value coverage if that is important to you. You don't have that option with later model car insurance but yet you still buy that type of policy anyway for your later model vehicles!

      WHY would you buy regular car insurance on your daily driver cars/trucks if Agreed Coverage is so important to you in other areas of insurance coverage such as collector cars? Seems like a flip/flop to me?

      It's apples to oranges really. The market value of a late model vehicle can be determined easily and accurately, so a stated market value (which is backed up with a good volume of data points) can easily attained. And gap insurance is good CYA insurance based on those market values.

      The cars we build and drive are essentially art on wheels, that we like to use, abuse and put at risk! And they tend to have intrinsic value based on rarity, modifications and sentimental value, all of which is purely objective and variable. Thus an agreed value is better suited since the a 'market' value on such an item can vary wildly.

    15. #35
      Join Date
      Dec 2004
      Location
      HILLBILLY HOLLYWOOD, TENNESSEE!!!
      Posts
      2,044
      Quote Originally Posted by Tony_SS View Post
      It's apples to oranges really. The market value of a late model vehicle can be determined easily and accurately, so a stated market value (which is backed up with a good volume of data points) can easily attained. And gap insurance is good insurance on your insurance!

      The cars we build and drive are essentially art on wheels, that we like to use, abuse and put at risk! And they tend to have intrinsic value based on rarity, modifications and sentimental value, all of which is purely objective and variable. Thus an agreed value is better suited since the a 'market' value on such an item can vary wildly.
      I agree the market value on an item can vary depending upon many factors including condition, location and more. Sentimental value has $0.00 value in the insurance business. Yet contrary to your assertion there are accepted industry standards that can also determine the market value of your collector car on the date of loss.

      I in NO way have said that Agreed Value insurance is not a good thing to have. All I have stated is that you need to have the proper coverage for your needs/uses of the vehicle which may not fit an Agreed Value policy and may fit a Stated Value policy.

      Again just make sure the coverage you retain whether Stated Value coverage or Agreed Value coverage is proper for your needs and the use of the vehicle. Nothing More or Nothing Less!
      Mike

      Remember, "Drive Fast, Turn Heads, Break Hearts!"

      www.musclecardeals.com

    16. #36
      Join Date
      Apr 2001
      Location
      The City of Fountains
      Posts
      16,130
      Country Flag: United States
      I found this thread and there is a ton of good info here. I have a question that someone may know the answer to:

      Is there anything preventing an individual from having more than one insurance policy on a vehicle?

      I don't know if that even makes sense to do, but it's a question that popped into my head.

      Andrew
      1970 GTO Version 3.0
      1967 Cougar build
      GM High-Tech Performance feature
      My YouTube Channel Please Subscribe!
      Instagram @dr__efi
      I deliver what EFI promises.
      Remote Holley EFI tuning.
      Please get in touch if I can be of service.

      "You were the gun, your voice was the trigger, your bravery was the barrel, your eyes were the bullets." ~ Her

    17. #37
      Join Date
      Dec 2004
      Location
      HILLBILLY HOLLYWOOD, TENNESSEE!!!
      Posts
      2,044
      [QUOTE=andrewb70;904057
      Is there anything preventing an individual from having more than one insurance policy on a vehicle?
      Andrew[/QUOTE]


      No!

      Having 2 policies does not mean you will get paid twice for the same loss.

      In a total you the insured can only provide the title to the car to one insuror so you cannot get paid twice in a total loss.

      In the case of a less than total loss one insuror would be primary and the second insuror would be the secondary insuror with the secondary insuror only paying for what the primary insuror did not pay for to make you "whole" prior to the loss.

      If you read the terms and conditions of most any insurance policy this questions will be addressed. It is possible that seeking "Full" payment for a loss from both insuror's for the same damage claim may be insurance fraud in many states. Call your state insurance commission for an answer to this question.
      Mike

      Remember, "Drive Fast, Turn Heads, Break Hearts!"

      www.musclecardeals.com

    18. #38
      Join Date
      Apr 2001
      Location
      The City of Fountains
      Posts
      16,130
      Country Flag: United States
      Quote Originally Posted by vintageracer View Post
      No!

      Having 2 policies does not mean you will get paid twice for the same loss.

      In a total you the insured can only provide the title to the car to one insuror so you cannot get paid twice in a total loss.

      In the case of a less than total loss one insuror would be primary and the second insuror would be the secondary insuror with the secondary insuror only paying for what the primary insuror did not pay for to make you "whole" prior to the loss.

      If you read the terms and conditions of most any insurance policy this questions will be addressed. It is possible that seeking payment from both insuror's for the same claim may be insurance fraud in many states. Call you state insurance commission for an answer to this question.
      Thanks Mike!

      Andrew
      1970 GTO Version 3.0
      1967 Cougar build
      GM High-Tech Performance feature
      My YouTube Channel Please Subscribe!
      Instagram @dr__efi
      I deliver what EFI promises.
      Remote Holley EFI tuning.
      Please get in touch if I can be of service.

      "You were the gun, your voice was the trigger, your bravery was the barrel, your eyes were the bullets." ~ Her

    19. #39
      Join Date
      Jan 2003
      Location
      Arizona
      Posts
      5,394
      Country Flag: United States
      The man to call is **** Ferguson over at Hartland Insurance. He will provide competitive collector car insurance AND set you up with weekend on-track Track Day coverage for your pro-touring car. The way it works is that you will pay a premium with deductible for the weekend that covers you against major incident or total loss. For example, if you have a minor "off" such that your car's exhaust is damaged, the repair will likely fall under your deductible. If, however, you run out of talent and crash into a jersey barrier, the major damage or loss is covered. I'm sure my explanation is less than precise, but the message is clear. It's a good idea for enthusiasts who attend track days once or twice per year. I think average coverage runs like $500K per event depending on the value of the car, of course.

      That sounds like a lot, but it beats writing off a valuable pro-touring car, Z06 or anything of real value for that matter. And if you frequently track your car, they have race coverage.

      http://www.hartlandinsurancegroup.com/motorsport.html
      ________________
      Steve Chryssos

    20. #40
      Join Date
      Feb 2010
      Location
      Arlington, VA
      Posts
      37
      I am in the process of moving, and I will no longer have a daily driver when I get to my new destination (using public transportation for my main means of getting around). Right now my Elco is insured through Hagerty, but they require me to have a separate daily driver to insure it.

      Does anyone know of another agreed value insurance provider that does not have a requirement for another daily driver? I can still accept all the same milage and usage restrictions, but I am not going to own another car.

    Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 1 2 3 LastLast



    Advertise on Pro-Touring.com