Enter your username:
Do you want to login or register?
  • Forgot your password?

    Login / Register




    Page 2 of 4 FirstFirst 1 2 3 4 LastLast
    Results 21 to 40 of 67
    1. #21
      Join Date
      Aug 2004
      Posts
      2,413
      Finally, these nut jobs point out that, since they're using their "magic force changing directional metallic tubes" and their "super fancy force spreading mounting points", you would ultimately have to CRUSH THE ENTIRE FIREWALL REARWARD INTO THE BODY OF THE CAR IN ORDER TO GET ANY VERTICAL MOVEMENT OF THE FRAME. And since that entire firewall is supported by, oh, buttloads of metal, that's pretty much impossible.



      I believe we can all see how simply preposterous this is. since these magic force tubes are only supported by, oh, say, the laws of physics (which are highly suspect these days, apparently!), there is ultimately no reason to even presume the second school of thought might be right.

      Herb adams, how could we have ever trusted you? After your decades of race experience and completely revolutionary designs that are time-tested and the basis for a massive chunk of racing technology even today, the "gnorw" thinkers have finally shown you for what you truly were: a BIG FAT STINKY FAKE.

      You know what? I bet ol' smokey yunick was just as big of a liar. I shall never trust another racing legend, ever again.

      Remind me to throw my chassis braces out in the morning. In fact, I'll just go ask my 3 year old to yank them out for me.
      __________________
      ^^^^ thats funny right there I dont care who you are. Thank you for putting it in a way I cant.
      Nothing says "I built this" better than tool marks and dykem blue..

      Follow my 3 link build. https://www.pro-touring.com/forum/sh...ad.php?t=61592


    2. #22
      Join Date
      Nov 2001
      Location
      Sacramento Ca
      Posts
      6,827
      Country Flag: United States
      LOL

      Good post.
      Tony Langlois
      1966 Corvair Monza

    3. #23
      Join Date
      Mar 2007
      Location
      Calgary, Alberta, Canada
      Posts
      23
      Really enjoyed that, Formula

      Quote Originally Posted by SatisTraction

      snip

      and if that red car belongs to herb adams i know all i need to know about his engineering.

      snip
      Actually, the red car doesn't belong to Herb Adams. Just one that showed up on ebay a while back that had some of the parts he used to sell.

      Here's one that he did own:

      Steve

      1978 WS6-W72 4-speed Trans Am: Fire-Am Restification Project
      VSE front and rear sway bars, solid spherical control arm and spring eye bushings, front springs trimmed 1/2 coil, VSE aluminum oil pan and baffle; Pro-Touring F-Body solid aluminum subframe bushings, 1980 WS6 rear disk brake system, 12" 1LE front disk brakes, Alston cowl-to-subframe Y-braces and subframe connectors, Moser axles, Hooker chrome roll bar, Corbeau GT-8 seats.

      2000 WS6 Trans Am M6

    4. #24
      Join Date
      Aug 2004
      Location
      Harriman, Tennessee
      Posts
      1,310
      Country Flag: United States
      Quote Originally Posted by LowBuckX
      Solid Mounts and subframe connectors already inmstalled...
      I will have to try and find a pic of what you are taking about on the other brace.

      Thanks PT442 Neki67 Go for it
      I'll dig around and see what I can come up with... I was sure I took pictures of the ones I used for the 442, but they aren't on the computer. If I find one, I'll have it scanned and post it.

      Shiny Side Up!
      Bill
      ’72 442 “Inamorata”
      www.FQuick.com/ProTouring442
      "You can never go home again, Oatman...


      But I guess you can shop there."

    5. #25
      Join Date
      Apr 2001
      Location
      Central CA USA
      Posts
      6,114
      Country Flag: United States
      I've seen a few of these braces on cars, one of them is on a buddy's 69 camaro who open tracks the car, the firewall is not damaged at all. I would recommend however that you make the firewall brackets a bit wider on the inside tubes to reduce the chances of any localized bending of the firewall.

      Also note the Adams tubes are straighter than yours, this helps the stiffness a lot, try to make yours as straight as possible.

      Herb Adams was and is a real suspension engineer who has more credentials and experience than most aftermarket "tuners". That said, he's only human and in my opinion he's better at engineering than fabrication. By that I mean his parts are based on solid theory but a more skilled fabricator would be able to produce a nicer looking part.
      David
      Last edited by David Pozzi; 03-11-2007 at 09:55 AM.
      67 Camaro RS that will be faster than anything Mary owns.

    6. #26
      Join Date
      Aug 2004
      Posts
      2,413
      Point taken But I cannot make them any straighter because I have to go around stuff.
      As for the mounting point on the inside bar I will be reinforceing the wall from the inside to distribute to pressure yet be unseen
      Nothing says "I built this" better than tool marks and dykem blue..

      Follow my 3 link build. https://www.pro-touring.com/forum/sh...ad.php?t=61592

    7. #27
      Join Date
      Aug 2004
      Posts
      194

      It's possible one of the arrows on the firewall is backwards. The bars may act as a class 2 lever meaning the lower firewall mount would be pulling instead of pushing on the firewall.


      Since your mounts are close to horizontal, (guessing a 15* angle) the upward force at the control arm mount could rotate along that plane like a hinge.

      If either of those assumptions are true, then moving the lower bars further down the firewall might improve their effectiveness. I'd also like to add that I'm a fan of Herb Adams and I have no reason to doubt his engineering ability.

      Quote Originally Posted by SatisTraction
      try this. unbolt them from the control arm mount and then see how little force it takes to flex the firewall.
      Even if you don't agree with him about the usefulness of the bars, that would be a simple test to see if they worked. And if they didn't work as you expected, you might see how to make them work better.


      This if off topic, but I just wanted to add that I always wanted to see a rubber bumpered Camaro without the bumper running across the grille.

    8. #28
      Join Date
      Aug 2004
      Posts
      2,413
      As per David I have cut off the top mount and made a larger mounting pad and moveid it a bit down the wall.

      Lets address the strength of the Firewall. It is not flimsy at all.

      See the red I have marked in this pic? You can see where the Wiper machanism/ventilation troff is.

      That Is adding alot of strength Then what I have marked B is the new mounting location with a larger pad.

      You can see the internal workings here in this line drawing Ive made. Its not just a sheet of tin tacked up there. The bodys on our sub framed cars are made stronger than you think.


      Nothing says "I built this" better than tool marks and dykem blue..

      Follow my 3 link build. https://www.pro-touring.com/forum/sh...ad.php?t=61592

    9. #29
      Join Date
      Jun 2005
      Location
      Greenwood, SC
      Posts
      2,314
      Quote Originally Posted by Beige
      It's possible one of the arrows on the firewall is backwards. The bars may act as a class 2 lever meaning the lower firewall mount would be pulling instead of pushing on the firewall.

      Entirely true, and an excellent point. In fact, I'd almost think there's no way it could not be acting like a class 2 lever. I actually considered this when making my drawings, but started having more fun than paying attention to detail. I would presume that that's the entire point of the lower bars-- granted, they could still be taking some rearward force, but not much compared to the upper bars. The angle the lower bars make compared to the UCA mounts is pretty severe.

      Quote Originally Posted by Beige
      This if off topic, but I just wanted to add that I always wanted to see a rubber bumpered Camaro without the bumper running across the grille.
      Ditto! that thing looks really cool...I now have a reason to look for a later second gen camaro to play around with some day.

    10. #30
      Join Date
      Mar 2007
      Location
      Calgary, Alberta, Canada
      Posts
      23
      Quote Originally Posted by formula
      Ditto! that thing looks really cool...I now have a reason to look for a later second gen camaro to play around with some day.
      Its actually a VSE front end:

      Steve

      1978 WS6-W72 4-speed Trans Am: Fire-Am Restification Project
      VSE front and rear sway bars, solid spherical control arm and spring eye bushings, front springs trimmed 1/2 coil, VSE aluminum oil pan and baffle; Pro-Touring F-Body solid aluminum subframe bushings, 1980 WS6 rear disk brake system, 12" 1LE front disk brakes, Alston cowl-to-subframe Y-braces and subframe connectors, Moser axles, Hooker chrome roll bar, Corbeau GT-8 seats.

      2000 WS6 Trans Am M6

    11. #31
      Join Date
      Apr 2001
      Location
      Central CA USA
      Posts
      6,114
      Country Flag: United States
      I think you need to keep the inner brace attached to the top of the firewall, I feel there is more strength there. I'd just make the mount plate wider left to right like 3" to 4" wide total, and have it cover the top and front of the firewall with a 90 deg bend in it. A reinforcing plate can be put inside the firewall plenum if needed for extra strength. The outer firewall tubes connect to the fender bolt and should be pretty secure there.

      The main benefit of these from what I recall is, the increase in torsional rigidity. I'm sure they also help in beaming stiffness but torsional stiffness is most important for handling.
      David
      Last edited by David Pozzi; 03-12-2007 at 09:46 PM.
      67 Camaro RS that will be faster than anything Mary owns.

    12. #32
      Join Date
      May 2005
      Posts
      136
      Any reason why they are attached to the UCA's? Would it be better if they were moved front more? Like to the bottom of the rad support, but still welded/bolted to the frame? I might see about doing this to my car. It has a front subframe that is removable, I imagine like Camaros? Dont beat on the Mopar guy So for attachment to the firewall, a plate inside that is also welded as well would help?

    13. #33
      Join Date
      Aug 2004
      Posts
      2,413
      Well damn it Dave..lol I just got done with making changes that I beleive will be good.1/4" 2.5 x 3" plate backed with a 1/4 plate of the same size inside.

      I think Im staying with this.



      Rb In my eyes the tube will be weaker if you made it much longer.
      Nothing says "I built this" better than tool marks and dykem blue..

      Follow my 3 link build. https://www.pro-touring.com/forum/sh...ad.php?t=61592

    14. #34
      Join Date
      Mar 2002
      Location
      Redwood City, CA
      Posts
      1,895,413,640
      Country Flag: United States
      Quote Originally Posted by rb70383
      Any reason why they are attached to the UCA's? Would it be better if they were moved front more? Like to the bottom of the rad support, but still welded/bolted to the frame?
      The reason it's bolted to the control arm stud is because that's where the force is being effected. The force goes directly from the source of the flex to the firewall. The reason on the second gen that it's bolted to the firewall lip is because that is the strongest part of the firewall. It's also bolted to the fender bolt on the firewall. That part is also a reinforced part.

      Dave, the first gen firewall is a little different from the second gen for that very reason. I think where Shawn has it mounted is similar in structure to where the second gen bar mounts.

      Looks good to me Shawn. Let us know what you feel. I'll bet it's more than you might have thought it would be.
      Allen Ortega
      Meanstreets Performance Fabrication

      ---------------------------------------

      Vegetarians are the reason for global warming

    15. #35
      Join Date
      Apr 2006
      Location
      Atlanta GA
      Posts
      7,477
      that guy was drinking..



      i really like those bars.. might want a set myself!

    16. #36
      Join Date
      Mar 2005
      Location
      Jackson Ms
      Posts
      1,220
      Quote Originally Posted by Venomous Type
      that guy was drinking..



      i really like those bars.. might want a set myself!
      no, i just think it is an uneffective mod, i have a junk camaro i may try it on one day if i am bored. I can see it being effective if it was tied to a cage and welded to the frame. with a singal attachment point on a control bolt and bolted to sheet metal i say it is JUNK. it will pivot at the control arm bolt no matter how tight he gets it. that will make the top bar push in and the lower one pull out. now if it is was welded to the frame or mounted to BOTH control arm bolts it would not pivot there and try to lift the body when the frame flexed. However, as it is now the frame will flex just as much and put cyclic stress on the firewall. Lowbucks original upper mount was better to start with. atleast it was in two plains instead of the single plain that is in now.

      that yellow car that belongs to herb is NICE. it is also a TRACK car with a CAGE in it. I would also bet the body is mounted SOLID to the frame.

      SO to sum it up, i do not HATE Lowbuck. I do think his design is flawed and I am not jumping on a "cool" band wagon to fluff any egos.
      Chris V
      SOLD


    17. #37
      Join Date
      May 2005
      Posts
      136
      LowBuckX - True shorter is stronger.
      zbugger - I got it now! duh.....

      SatisTraction:
      I see where you are coming from as well. I was thinknig that too, however, What about when cages are tied into the floor? To me it seems like the same concept. I do agree that mounting to both UCA bolts would prevent any pivoting the lower mount might have.

    18. #38
      Join Date
      Aug 2004
      Posts
      2,413
      How many times does one person have to be proved wrong before he goes away. Again I didnot ask your opinion.
      Nothing says "I built this" better than tool marks and dykem blue..

      Follow my 3 link build. https://www.pro-touring.com/forum/sh...ad.php?t=61592

    19. #39
      Join Date
      Apr 2006
      Location
      California Bay Area
      Posts
      235
      I think since the car is a unibody that mounting it to the firewall would be effective its not just sheet metal its the car.That yellow camaro makes me want a second gen really bad and dse didnt help by making a minitub kit.I think if you got the bars engraved and gold plated they would add horsepower to
      65 Impala
      01 Z06

    20. #40
      Join Date
      Mar 2005
      Location
      Jackson Ms
      Posts
      1,220
      Quote Originally Posted by LowBuckX
      How many times does one person have to be proved wrong before he goes away. Again I didnot ask your opinion.
      i was gone until i read the bashing i was taking. I agree with the theory behind what you are trying to do. I just do not agree with the way you are doing it. You have not proved me wrong with your fabrication. Do you want to? Take a 0-100 pound fish scale and hook to the control arm bolt hole and pull it up. see how many pounds of force it takes to move the bars. I am not sure how much movement would be considered passing but i doubt the frame flexes more then 1/8" if it mounted solidly to the body.

      one thing that concerns me safety wise? how are you mounting it to the control arm bolt? are you using a second nut or the control arm nut? The single contol arm nut is not the best idea. It will pivot there and loosen the single nut. The control arm nut, followed by a washer, the channel, washer, and then a locking nut would be less likely to loosen.
      Chris V
      SOLD


    Page 2 of 4 FirstFirst 1 2 3 4 LastLast



    Advertise on Pro-Touring.com