Enter your username:
Do you want to login or register?
  • Forgot your password?

    Login / Register




    Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 LastLast
    Results 1 to 20 of 43
    1. #1
      Join Date
      Jul 2003
      Location
      Anaheim Hills, CA
      Posts
      11,967
      Country Flag: United States

      Anyone here do home HVAC stuff?

      AC went out.. turned out to just be a transformer ($450) but the failure was caused by the water leaking down from the coil unit. Seems the old drip pan is rusted through.

      The current system is an old 50,00 btu Lennox Whisper Heat furnace and a Lenox AC unit.

      It's old, I doubt it's very efficient and the tech showed me on his scope how corroded the inside of the unit is.

      Ok, so they are trying to sell me a new system.. my problem is that I don't know what's good/bad in terms of a deal or what this stuff costs.

      The company seems good.. they have good ratings, good testimonials and offer a lifetime (transferable with the house) warranty. A few BBB complaints but they addressed them it seems.

      http://www.servicechampions.com/index.php

      The price for a new system.. including permits, tax, labor and all that junk is $10,200 otd.

      That doesn't include the two federal rebates ($1500 and $1000) or my local $300 rebate.

      Here are the main parts:

      SSX160361 condensor
      CE60D44 coil
      GME80703BX furnace

      Internet prices seem to be around $5k in parts.. so that leaves $5k in labor. Seems like a lot for a one day deal.

      install would include new condenson pad, all new coper lines, new t-stat, pretty much everything except new duct work. Again, lifetime warranty and yada yada..

      The only part that bugged me is he told me it's Amana stuff.. but those numbers come up Goodman, not Amana.. I asked if this was rebadged Goodman and he said no. He didn't seem dishonest so maybe he just screwed up.

      Thoughts? It's a LOT of $$$ and I don't know if this is a good/fair price or not for what we are getting.

      House is 1962 (bad/missing wall insulation back then) single story 1500 sq ft house (four bedrooms) in southern california (high 30s in the winters.. over 100 in the summer.. not much humidity)

      Need to get this sorted out quickly and really don't know which way to go.

      Thoughts?

      If it is a Goodman is that a good brand? Isn't Amana a part of Maytag?
      "A ship in port is safe, but that's not what ships are built for."

      1968 Track Rat Camaro:
      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SGHJ5c1yLIo&t=2s

      1971 Chevelle Wagon with a few mods:
      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WBVPR3sRgyU

    2. #2
      Join Date
      Dec 2006
      Location
      oshawa ontario
      Posts
      1,607
      Country Flag: Canada
      I own a residential Hvac company since '03, 23 yrs as a service tech.....I dont know how much permits amount to but that is a lot of $$ for a furnace and A/C.....it better be their absolute top of the line equipment.....my middle of the road furn/A/C combo's (the ones I sell the most of by far) go for about 5Gs....that is a York/Luxaire 2 stage gas furnace and a single stage 13 Seer A/C.....my top of the line Furn (fully modulating burner and variable speed main blower motor) goes for 4Gs.....

      the thing you gotta ask yourself is "what am I going to do with the house?".....if your going to stay then you'll get your money out of the top shelf equip, if not then your buying it for the next guy.

      As far as Goodman....their reputation is "builder grade" equipment (cheap) but I do give them credit they are trying very hard to change that rep with equipment that is as high tech as most of them, but its not an easy road.......IMO the two best are Carrier and York....Carrier is the most high tech but the York is very close behind (I can explain) and less money but IMO you cannot go wrong with either product .....

      what do I have in my house? a Carrier furnace and a Comfort Air A/C (I would have put in a York A/C but Comfort Air makes a specialized product that I could mount high on the wall allowing me to park my race car trailer underneath.....go figure!.....after 23 yrs the bulk of my customers are people I know in some way so I cant sell junk and I have no time whatsoever for problem PITA manufactures like Lennox and Rheem, I have no problem whatsoever installing the York/Luxaire product to friends and family.
      Nascar 69 Chevelle project, 1999 Hutch Pagan Nascar chassis, 69 Chevelle body,700hp, Penske's, slicks, roadrace track day https://www.pro-touring.com/showthre...le-Cup-project
      89 Iroc 406 Fitech 5 spd
      01 chevy 2500HD 4x4 8.1 Allison
      31 Scarab 2 x 454

    3. #3
      Join Date
      Dec 2006
      Location
      oshawa ontario
      Posts
      1,607
      Country Flag: Canada
      An Ammana is a Goodman with a different sticker....we dont have Maytags up here.

      And as we say up here he "hosed" you on that trans man.....the transformer for a Whisper (Ive seen hundreds of Whisper's) cost me about 30 bucks....take it from there

      IMO you may want to shop around for a small contractor (maybe one with his personal name as his company) who sells a major brand like York or Carrier.....that way he's putting his personal name on every job you'll likely have the same service tech every time for service and maintaince (not a different guy every time)...... he doesnt have the overhead ($$)of a big shop so you'll get better prices for sure and if he sells a major brand if you have a falling out with him you can call up another company in the area who will be familiar with the product.
      Nascar 69 Chevelle project, 1999 Hutch Pagan Nascar chassis, 69 Chevelle body,700hp, Penske's, slicks, roadrace track day https://www.pro-touring.com/showthre...le-Cup-project
      89 Iroc 406 Fitech 5 spd
      01 chevy 2500HD 4x4 8.1 Allison
      31 Scarab 2 x 454

    4. #4
      Join Date
      Nov 2007
      Location
      Lafayette, LA, USA
      Posts
      485
      Country Flag: Canada
      I wish I could say I had any luck with my local HVAC people but I think they are all crooks from what I have seen (sorry not trying to offend anyone). I would get at least 3 or 4 quotes to see what is up. Normally I just do 2 quotes but on a major purchase I think it warrants more information. My boss is in the process of having problems and his quote was a little over $6k so 10k sounds crazy high.

      I lived in my house for 8 years and had numerous hvac people in for service as well I had a maintenance plan for a few years. Last week I came home to two flooded A/C units with thousands of dollars in water damage. I had them serviced in the winter (cost me $700 for a couple of relays or some BS) but he did the same lame ass checks that I have watched every other clown do over the last decade. Both units had back up catch pans with flow switches and the whole ****tin capoodle failed. Nice. Anyways, sorry for the rant but HVAC people are on my crap list this week.

      When I had problems last winter I posted some questions on this site and got some very useful responses. It might not hurt to get some other opinions for general knowledge sakes. The general consensus I found from the site was that Tranes (sp?) where the best.

      Here is the link to my post about what my last HVAC yahoo considers normal.
      Life's journey is not to arrive at the grave safely in a well preserved body, but rather to skid in sideways, totally worn out, shouting - Holy cow - what a ride!!!
      See my build

      Jason

    5. #5
      Join Date
      Jul 2003
      Location
      Anaheim Hills, CA
      Posts
      11,967
      Country Flag: United States
      Quote Originally Posted by shortrack View Post
      my middle of the road furn/A/C combo's (the ones I sell the most of by far) go for about 5Gs....that is a York/Luxaire 2 stage gas furnace and a single stage 13 Seer A/C......
      Yea, I got that vibe too.. they did the hard sell but I said I had to research (the whole, well if you say yes today you get a better price than tomorrow deal)

      I looked online and I don't see the equipment being over $5k.. hell, closer to $4k so how much could labor possibly be? Only stuff in the attic are the copper lines from the condensor to the coil.

      And I don't like that he told me it's Amana and not rebadged Goodman when it is for sure Goodman..

      I was seriously thinking 5-6k installed.. the $10k blew my mind.

      Oh, and he mentioned two rebates.. one $1500 one (fed stimi) that I knew of and some other new $1000 one that I can't find any info on.
      "A ship in port is safe, but that's not what ships are built for."

      1968 Track Rat Camaro:
      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SGHJ5c1yLIo&t=2s

      1971 Chevelle Wagon with a few mods:
      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WBVPR3sRgyU

    6. #6
      Join Date
      Jul 2003
      Location
      Anaheim Hills, CA
      Posts
      11,967
      Country Flag: United States
      Quote Originally Posted by shortrack View Post
      An Ammana is a Goodman with a different sticker....we dont have Maytags up here.

      And as we say up here he "hosed" you on that trans man.....the transformer for a Whisper (Ive seen hundreds of Whisper's) cost me about 30 bucks....take it from there

      IMO you may want to shop around for a small contractor (maybe one with his personal name as his company) who sells a major brand like York or Carrier.....that way he's putting his personal name on every job you'll likely have the same service tech every time for service and maintaince (not a different guy every time)...... he doesnt have the overhead ($$)of a big shop so you'll get better prices for sure and if he sells a major brand if you have a falling out with him you can call up another company in the area who will be familiar with the product.
      Yea, I wasn't about to pay over $400 for damn transformer.. you wouldn't know the part number and where I could get one would ya? lol
      "A ship in port is safe, but that's not what ships are built for."

      1968 Track Rat Camaro:
      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SGHJ5c1yLIo&t=2s

      1971 Chevelle Wagon with a few mods:
      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WBVPR3sRgyU

    7. #7
      Join Date
      Jul 2008
      Location
      ATL
      Posts
      678
      you are definately getting hosed

      I just bought an additional 2 ton unit for my house with the coil, condensor and air handler / gas heater for 1800. when you add the line some duct it was about 2500 total parts. That is a top of the line lenox 410 unit with a high seer rating.

      That was wholesale since I have several epa cert techs that work for me at my data center so I have wholesale accounts at the distributors.

      I paid 2.5 days of install time on it which was about another 500$ my cost.

      If you paid a retatil shop for this it would be about 5K.

      This is what they are quoting you - a 16 seer r410 system 2 ton rating http://www.acunitdirect.com/goodman-...nditioner.html

      I think you are getting Rheemed> lol - get it hehee

      call someone and ask them what their hourly rate is to install a system and if you are only replacing your system figure on max 2 days of work. Definitely call a small shop. I think you will find that buying the gear online will save you a lot of money.

      buy it online - 2k - buy the line - 125 - buy any other mis parts - 500 (from home depot) - installed labor price @80 per hour - 1300 - total cost - 4K at worst 5k max
      HPDE is the greatest thing since sliced bread.
      So much to learn......so much $$ to do so lol


    8. #8
      Join Date
      Jul 2007
      Location
      Olathe, KS
      Posts
      1,158
      Country Flag: United States
      https://www.pro-touring.com/forum/sh...&postcount=268
      Quote Originally Posted by musclecarjohn View Post
      A/C is for woosies...we don't need no stinking A/C here on the coast.
      Quote Originally Posted by Steve1968LS2 View Post
      Thank you




    9. #9
      Join Date
      Aug 2004
      Location
      Rustburg, Virginia
      Posts
      3,436
      Country Flag: United States
      LMBO.........

      I agree with 10K being too high. Maybe it's a regional thing, but around here the best systems going (turn-key installed), is about $5K -$5500

      Get some more quotes....don't take any of those "buy today deals", it's just a game they play to get you to rush into something. Make sure they break out all of the items in their quote, so you can see what you're actually paying for.
      1970 RS/SS350 139K on the clock:
      89 TPI motor w/ 1pc rear seal coupled to a Viper T56 via Mcleod's modular bellhousing w/ hydraulic T/O bearing from the Viper, 12 bolt rear w/ 3.73 gearing, SC&C upper control arms, factory lowers with Delalums, C5 brakes at all four corners, Front Wheels 17x8's with Sumi 255/40/17 and Rear Wheels 17x9's with Sumi 275/40/17.
      Brief description of the work done so far can be found here: http://www.nastyz28.com/forum/showthread.php?t=112454


    10. #10
      Join Date
      Dec 2006
      Location
      oshawa ontario
      Posts
      1,607
      Country Flag: Canada
      Quote Originally Posted by wicked68 View Post
      call someone and ask them what their hourly rate is to install a system and if you are only replacing your system figure on max 2 days of work. Definitely call a small shop. I think you will find that buying the gear online will save you a lot of money.

      buy it online - 2k - buy the line - 125 - buy any other mis parts - 500 (from home depot) - installed labor price @80 per hour - 1300 - total cost - 4K at worst 5k max
      I would make sure you have that set up with a contractor BEFORE you buy online......I get that prob 2 or 3 times a week and their never your brand of course.....someone buys a system online or from Costco or wherever and they want me to come and install it and of course cover warranty....heres my stock answer to that request......"So lets get this straight....you buy a unit yourself specifically to keep ME out of it, then you turn around and want me to simply look the other way and come over and install it AND cover warranty....why would I do that? if thats the way you want to do it then you should call the fireman down the street who puts A/Cs in on the side...no thanks, click"......thats the way that looks from this side of the fence....
      Nascar 69 Chevelle project, 1999 Hutch Pagan Nascar chassis, 69 Chevelle body,700hp, Penske's, slicks, roadrace track day https://www.pro-touring.com/showthre...le-Cup-project
      89 Iroc 406 Fitech 5 spd
      01 chevy 2500HD 4x4 8.1 Allison
      31 Scarab 2 x 454

    11. #11
      Join Date
      Dec 2006
      Location
      oshawa ontario
      Posts
      1,607
      Country Flag: Canada
      Quote Originally Posted by Steve1968LS2 View Post
      Yea, I wasn't about to pay over $400 for damn transformer.. you wouldn't know the part number and where I could get one would ya? lol
      you could mark the wires, take your old one out and go to the local hvac wholesale desk slap it on the counter and say "I need one of these" any 110/24v 40va (might be 20va, you'll have to look on the sticker on the trans itself and match it) transformer will work.
      Nascar 69 Chevelle project, 1999 Hutch Pagan Nascar chassis, 69 Chevelle body,700hp, Penske's, slicks, roadrace track day https://www.pro-touring.com/showthre...le-Cup-project
      89 Iroc 406 Fitech 5 spd
      01 chevy 2500HD 4x4 8.1 Allison
      31 Scarab 2 x 454

    12. #12
      Join Date
      Aug 2004
      Location
      Rustburg, Virginia
      Posts
      3,436
      Country Flag: United States
      Quote Originally Posted by shortrack View Post
      you could mark the wires, take your old one out and go to the local hvac wholesale desk slap it on the counter and say "I need one of these" any 110/24v 40va (might be 20va, you'll have to look on the sticker on the trans itself and match it) transformer will work.
      +1....and while you're in there....repair or replace that condensate pan or you'll keep eating transformers.
      1970 RS/SS350 139K on the clock:
      89 TPI motor w/ 1pc rear seal coupled to a Viper T56 via Mcleod's modular bellhousing w/ hydraulic T/O bearing from the Viper, 12 bolt rear w/ 3.73 gearing, SC&C upper control arms, factory lowers with Delalums, C5 brakes at all four corners, Front Wheels 17x8's with Sumi 255/40/17 and Rear Wheels 17x9's with Sumi 275/40/17.
      Brief description of the work done so far can be found here: http://www.nastyz28.com/forum/showthread.php?t=112454


    13. #13
      Join Date
      Feb 2005
      Location
      Indianapolis, Indiana
      Posts
      337
      Country Flag: United States

      Anyone here do home HVAC stuff?

      Actually a post I can commit on! I work at Carrier in Indianapolis. We manufacture the residential heating and fan coil products here. Just an FYI we also do Bryant and the ICP (International Comfort Prodcuts). I personally would find a dealer that does all of our stuff. This would allow you the best deal possible. As far as your furnace it would come from Indianapolis. Your A/C and heat pumps are made in Collierville, TN, as well as potentially the case coil for your furnace. Normally, the Carrier stuff is top of the line. The big thing with the Bryant stuff is the Puron refrigerant. ICP stuff is slightly cheaper, but still great quality. ICP furnace uses a different primary heat exchanger design than the Carrier/Bryant in the mid eff. line. The primarys are also different in the high eff. line between the ICP and the Carrier/Bryant line. The secondary heat exchangers in the ICP is a tube and plate design, and in the Carrier/Bryant line poly coated plate design. The both secondary is pretty rugged and all have a great warranty. I personally would have them show you the pros and cons on Carrier versus Bryant and potentially ICP, if the rep all of them. What it will boil down to is options. These might be zone cooling and if the unit is multi-speed and such.
      Ben Mowery

      67 Firebird -Powered by Pontiac w/ RAM AIR V.

    14. #14
      Join Date
      Jul 2003
      Location
      Anaheim Hills, CA
      Posts
      11,967
      Country Flag: United States
      Quote Originally Posted by John Wright View Post
      +1....and while you're in there....repair or replace that condensate pan or you'll keep eating transformers.
      Looks like you would have to remove most of the system to get to the pan.

      I will most likely get it working and start shopping around for a new system.

      As for the transformer, he removed the one he put in and didn't reinstall my old one so marking the wires isn't gonna work.

      Lastly it's a 3 Ton quoted not a 2 ton.. still, I think it's too much $$$. Lastly I didn't want a Goodman, especially at that price.
      "A ship in port is safe, but that's not what ships are built for."

      1968 Track Rat Camaro:
      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SGHJ5c1yLIo&t=2s

      1971 Chevelle Wagon with a few mods:
      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WBVPR3sRgyU

    15. #15
      Join Date
      Feb 2006
      Posts
      39
      steve
      i

    16. #16
      Join Date
      Feb 2006
      Posts
      39
      steve
      i live in rhode island and i am fully licesened. i could fly out there with tools, buy the materials, do the job, go for a ride in your car, fly home, and save you money. that job is worth about $7500.
      forget the name when you buy a unit, find the best warranty.
      no body makes their own equipment. its just a bunch of random parts from other vendors dropped into their own package.

    17. #17
      Join Date
      Apr 2010
      Location
      Sunny Flordida
      Posts
      345
      I agree with Buddy about the warranty and his pricing is great, but will buddy fly back out there if it breaks?
      Key points to know (some have been mentioned, some have not):
      1. Unless you're in the a/c business, you can't possibly know that a lot of the different "brands" are actually made by the same manufacturers.
      2. A/C guys are like car mechanics - find a good one with a good reputation and NEVER let anyone else touch your system EVER again!
      3. It's worth a little extra $ up front to have piece of mind in who will be doing the job. (Are they going to come back out if it breaks?)
      4. Call the A/C # on the weekend. If they don't answer, they won't answer when your system breaks down on the weekend or on a holiday.
      5. Would you pay the lights, phone bill, insurance, advertising, gas, insurance, schooling, etc. etc, cost (not to mention the time it takes to run around and give homeowners the quotes, etc. they are asking for, on your dime) and then sell a $30 part for $40. It's offensive to think that a person shouldn't make a profit after cost, or be paid adequately for the expertise that they bring to the table. If something isn't worth the asking price then don't do it, or at least don't complain about it after you have.
      6. Price vs. Cost - Price is what you pay up front for something. Cost is what you pay over the lifetime of ownership. "It's better to pay more than you expected than it is to pay less than you should".
      AND "It's never good to pay too much for something. But paying too little is even worse. When you pay too much, you may lose a few dollars. When you pay too little, you can lose everything because the thing you bought doesn't even do what you bought it to do! If you are going to go on cost alone, put some money aside for the inevitable headaches and cost you're going to experience. If you're willing to do that, then you could go ahead and afford something nice".
      7. 3 estimates doesn't work. If it did, why would home improvements be one of the most complained about fields of business, according to the BBB? "I did what I was told, I got three estimates. I didn't go with the most expensive guys, or the cheapest. Yet, I still got screwed. Again, find someone who is time tested and proven to stand behind their work AND NEVER LOOK BACK!!! Plenty of people are going to tell you could have bought this or that for way cheaper. Let them deal with the headaches that come from "cheaper".

      My advise would be to find a good company, with a good reputation who is close enough to service the system in a timely manner. The system you purchase is only as good as who installs it. The manufacturer may have a great warranty, but as with every other product out there "Improper installation will void this warranty". Secondly, as mentioned above, are there service hours as such that they will come back out when you need them.

      I could go on and on, but these are some key things to take into consideration when purchasing an a/c or any other large purchase.

      [/URL]

    18. #18
      Join Date
      Mar 2006
      Location
      NW Burbs, IL
      Posts
      286
      GME80703BX furnace

      ^^^ That furnace is an 80% and won't qualify for a rebate:

      http://www.energystar.gov/index.cfm?...up&pgw_code=FU

      I replaced a 20yr old 90% for a 92.1% and made a huge difference.

      Then again you live in CA and probably do not spend a ton on gas bills? Maybe not worth the added cost of going more efficient?

      BTW, my Payne unit is a re-badged Carrier.

    19. #19
      Join Date
      Mar 2009
      Location
      Southern Maryland
      Posts
      402
      I was in the hvac industry for 8 years 2 of which were in sales. There was too much bs in that business for me so I got out and can be objective.

      What has been stated above is pretty good advice. The best being what are you going to do with the house? Live in it 2 years, live in it 10 or retire there. That should set what level of equipment you want. Goodman/Amana are the same thing, although the Amana has better warranties, although the Goodman is better than most of the other stuff on the market. Yes, they are owned by Maytag. Looks like they quoted you 16 SEER. I hope you plan to stay 10 years plus in that home. 99% of the parts in all manufacturers units are universal, especially all the electrical components. Everybody is making similar stuff these days, don't let anyone tell you they have something super special.

      Those who are saying that they sell top level systems for 5-7.5K are either not making any money or doing something shady. My top level systems were 15K+. I'd say $7,500 was average. This was not my company by the way. I would figure around $7,500 maybe for that system so $10K isn't that far off but I would expect closer to $8 off the top of my head, but I don't know the job either so there may be other circumstances I can't see.

      My recommendation, get a couple other estimates. As was stated above, ask if they will come and fix it at night or on weekends/holidays. What are they doing to train their guys? Is it a program or Bubba the 50 year vet teaching all his bad habits. It sounds to me like you found a modern company that is of a larger size that knows what it takes to stay in business for 50+ years. HVAC companies fail so often they are #2 only behind restaurants for their failure rate. Hope this helps.

    20. #20
      Join Date
      Aug 2008
      Location
      Pgh, PA
      Posts
      2,177
      I'm not in HVAC but I've slept in a Holiday Inn Express. And I just put a new unit (forced air gas) and AC in my house. I used a small private contractor who happens to be a friend of mine. However, I made sure he was charging me and not doing everything out of the kindness of his heart. He needs to feed his family and this is his business.

      He swears by American Standard, and that's what we put in. I have just a little less than $8K in from soup to nuts, but that was equipment, labor, and it wasn't an easy install. My house (including garage area) is about 5400sq/ft. Not including garage I'd say around 4000. Furnace is their Freedom 95 Comfort-R Variable Speed, which is about top of the line. AC wasn't the absolute top of the line, but is one of their upper models. The price also included a new filter assembly, and a new humidifier. All plumbing and electrical (including a condensate pump and routing) also included.

      Bottom line is that this was a large, high capacity, and high end system for just under $8K, and I assure you there was nothing shady about it. The contractor is as honest a person as you will ever meet in your entire life. I'd say look around - a private contractor may get you more bang for your buck if you shop enough.
      '66 GTO Vert Project "Red Ink", 462ci of stroked pontiac power, TKO600, SC&C Stg II+, Tubular lowers, Currectrac Rear suspension, Moser 12bolt w/Truetrack, Wilwood Master and discs all around, too much fun for words...

    Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 LastLast



    Advertise on Pro-Touring.com