Enter your username:
Do you want to login or register?
  • Forgot your password?

    Login / Register




    Results 1 to 20 of 29

    Hybrid View

    1. #1
      Join Date
      Aug 2004
      Location
      Montgomery, IL
      Posts
      359
      Country Flag: United States

      Agreed value vs. stated value vs. ACV

      I'm a claim manager and worked for the largest US auto insurer as well as the 4th largest commercial insurer. All insurance companies are regulated by the state in which they are licensed to do business. Unless contractually agreed upon via an appraisal or agreed value, all total losses are required to be settled based on the Actual Cash Value (ACV) of the property lost.

      ACV is generally defined as the retail (market) value of property. Insurers are allowed various means by the state to determine retail value but for the most part, no state allows an insurer to determine retail value strictly based on a "book" value when either sufficient market information is available to determine a retail value or the property in question has been professionally appraised.

      What this mean is that if you own a car for which there is sufficient market information to determine it's value or your car has been appraised, you should not have any major problems resolving your claim.



      The insurer has to start somewhere and they may begin with a suggested book value which if not contested by you would be considered a fair claim practice. The trick here is to make sure you have established the value of the car by providing pictures, receipts and ads for substantially similar cars to dispute that initial offer.

      For example, I had a claim from a guy who owned an 87 Buick Grand National. If you go to the Autometer site, I believe they still have a picture of it there. We used CCC (large independent firm that most insurers subscribe to that does nothing but maintain a huge database of the sale price of autos) to establish an inital value for the car when it was stolen. In 2000, it came back with a value of something like $12,000 in excellent condition with under 20K miles. The owner showed up on my office after my rep made that offer with a 2" binder with an appraisal, receipts and 50 or so pictures of the car. The receipts totalled about $34K and the claim was settled for $24,000 which was $1,000 more than the appraisal due to some things he added after the appraisal.

      If we did not reach an agreement, virtually every policy I have seen has an arbitration policy where the value is decided based on your documentation by three professional appraisors. You pick one, the insurer picks one and both of them pick a third. Agreement by any two settles your claim.

      The point is if you are not insured by a specialty you are not screwed as may seem to think. The problem is when some yahoo in his primered over rust, disco Nova with JC Whitney shackles and mismatched wheels thinks he's got a "classic" that's worth $25,000 'cause it is in number "2" condition when in reality, it's one step away from a basket case and in no way collectible. He's got nothing to back up the value as most of the parts were scavenged off of the other Nova he has on blocks out back. This guy gets "screwed" by getting $800 which is probably $300 more than he bought it for.

      Like anything that's worth a significant amount of money, you want to insure it and it's your responsibility to document what you have. Specialty policies that do not use appraisals and use an agreed value are a relatively new product that appears to meet the needs of our hobby very well. These policies probably represent a better choice than traditional policies although I have some concern over repairable vehicles that are not a total loss and how a total loss is determined in the first place.





    Advertise on Pro-Touring.com