Enter your username:
Do you want to login or register?
  • Forgot your password?

    Login / Register




    Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 1 2
    Results 21 to 33 of 33
    1. #21
      dennis68 Guest
      Psssst, MrQuicky. you need to weld the HTH kit in too.

      BTW, holy **** the arms are friken awesome. I'll have some more to post latter in the week. Let me get a dry day to play first, the water is killing me, it just gets all out of shape...no fun at 60MPH with tractor pulling doubles riding my ass.



    2. #22
      Join Date
      May 2002
      Location
      Northern California
      Posts
      10,716
      Country Flag: United States
      cool, let me know how it all works together... I know but they have done the testing and have honest experience. Carefull is all I wish to add.
      MrQuick ΜΟΛ'ΩΝ ΛΑΒ'Ε


    3. #23
      Join Date
      Jan 2005
      Posts
      160
      If we were going to leave the suspension stuff to the experts shouldn't we shut this forum down?

      My opinion is that if you want to delve into the world of suspension fabrication, there is no better place to start than with a live axle rear suspension. Yes, you need to know how to weld, yes, you should have at least some rudimentary knowledge of suspensions and yes, you're going to have to tune it yourself, but you definitely don't need to be an expert. There is absolutely no better way to learn than to build it, tune it and race it. All the books in the world won't make you faster than the guy who's done it.

      Please excuse me if this seems like a rant. My pet peeve on the 'net are the people who give no information but constantly hand out warnings about the danger and impending doom of this or that. If you're not that guy then forget about it. If you are, then I'm ranting about you......


      Wally

    4. #24
      Join Date
      Nov 2002
      Location
      state of confusion
      Posts
      1,499
      Country Flag: United States
      Might want to add "and have a logical approach to technical/mechanical things" to that list, Wally. Otherwise, guess which way the "hit-or-miss" approach to tuning will mostly end up.

      In the pics on the previous page, I keep thinking that small diagonal braces running forward and outward toward from opposite the truck arm chassis pickups to the main rails where the next lateral members connect would be a structurally better approach than placing the full demand of tire traction load (times some impact factor) on that crossmember with the huge hole cut alone. The tube size that I have in mind would weigh less than 3 lbs per foot and provide both higher local rigidity at the truck arm pickups and greater fatigue resistance to the crossmember (you really wouldn't want that thing to crack while in service).

      Yes, this may sound like I'm being a bit too conservative, but the NASCAR designs include similar bracing for their truck arm crossmembers (which don't have d/s hole cuts and are subject to far more frequent inspection than any street car would ever get). Sounds like you'd get a ton of peace of mind for less than 20 lbs of metal that's attached down low and near the mass centroid.

      Norm
      '08 GT coupe, 5M, suspension unstockish (the occasional track toy)
      '19 WRX, Turbo-H4/6M (the family sedan . . . seriously)
      Gone but not forgotten dep't:
      '01 Maxima 20AE 5M, '10 LGT 6M, '95 626, V6/5M; '79 Malibu, V8/4M-5M; '87 Maxima, V6/5M; '72 Pinto, I4/4M; '64 Dodge V8/3A

    5. #25
      Join Date
      Aug 2004
      Posts
      957
      Interesting thread. Seems to me that there are "basically" three types of folks that are interested in modifying their suspension. The first type generally believes that if you just replace all the bushings with polyurethane, and some powder coated springs and maybe a new sway bar, you are ready for Road Atlanta, look out world. The second type are a bit more deliberate, and these are the types of folks that DSE, HTH, WDE, and others supply to. These folks see or drive a pretty cool car, and want to duplicate it for themselves, because it "must" work really well. Heck, the guy that built that other car "must" know exactly what he is doing. These folks are willing to make compromises, but nothing terribly inconvenient or inventive on their part. They may try to learn a few concepts, and are probably the first to spurt out terms like "camber gain" or "roll center," but not really willing to learn that all of the issues are intertwined. And by the way, there is nothing wrong at all with either of these types of folks, nothing wrong at all.

      Then, there's the third group. These folks are never satisfied, usually or always feeling that there is a better way to do things. They research, learn, attempt, and if they fail they try again. These folks also understand that there will always be a compromise, that there is not a perfect solution, and make their decisions based upon what they feel are the most important attributes. If these folks bought a suspension kit, it would be because it's good, not marketing good, but functionally good. They'd probably only buy it in the first place if it was too inconvenient to build themselves. These folks actually DO drive their cars, fast, on the track, and are honest with themselves about how it performs.

      It's really all perspective, you will hear from all three classes of folks, certainly here due to the rapidly growing interest in this sector of the hobby. So when folks state that their feeling is that one solution is better than another, just keep in mind where they are coming from.

      So how does this all relate to the truck arm setup? In my OPINION, if you were to build a suspension setup on your own, there are other types of setups that offer fewer compromises than the Truck Arm. So far, in this thread and others as they relate to the truck arms, there is a serious lack of technical argument as to WHY they work "so well," and it is understandable from a proprietary standpoint from HTH, but honestly, the system is very, very basic.

      I keep thinking that small diagonal braces running forward and outward toward from opposite the truck arm chassis pickups to the main rails where the next lateral members connect would be a structurally better approach than placing the full demand of tire traction load (times some impact factor) on that crossmember with the huge hole cut alone.
      In addition, I would consider moving the existing angular links that run back and out, closer to the pickup point for the T/A mounts, i.e. move them inward as far as possible towards the vehicle centerline. You can run some small extensions that would tie these back to the frame connectors (the runs that run parallel to the vehicle centerline). This would also help reduce the bending moment that the crossmember would see. You don't need to run super thick wall tubing, it is all about triangulation.

      Mark

    6. #26
      Join Date
      Nov 2002
      Location
      state of confusion
      Posts
      1,499
      Country Flag: United States
      Quote Originally Posted by Mean 69
      So far, in this thread and others as they relate to the truck arms, there is a serious lack of technical argument as to WHY they work "so well," and it is understandable from a proprietary standpoint from HTH, but honestly, the system is very, very basic.
      The most obvious reason that they work as well as they do is because rear axle roll steer can not only be made a small value of vehicle roll understeer, but also because the roll steer won't vary a whole lot over suspension travel due to the length of the truck arms. That goes toward 'predictability' and 'driver confidence'. I can picture a couple of other considerations that might be part of a good truck arm setup but I have no derivation or proof of same (this may be where 'proprietary' begins . . .)

      Norm
      '08 GT coupe, 5M, suspension unstockish (the occasional track toy)
      '19 WRX, Turbo-H4/6M (the family sedan . . . seriously)
      Gone but not forgotten dep't:
      '01 Maxima 20AE 5M, '10 LGT 6M, '95 626, V6/5M; '79 Malibu, V8/4M-5M; '87 Maxima, V6/5M; '72 Pinto, I4/4M; '64 Dodge V8/3A

    7. #27
      Join Date
      May 2002
      Location
      Northern California
      Posts
      10,716
      Country Flag: United States

      just thinking of the safety end of it

      Forgive me Wally for my glass half empty look towards this but Im just trying to avoid having a novice builder looking at this thread and saying "hey I could build that myself". I try to offer as much advice as I can but this is the best advice I can give in this situation...its alot better than a ueligy at a funeral where im apologizing.
      Again just a warning to those that may not have the experience others have. This kit or others isn't just bolting on a pair of subframe connectors. This is something that can be potentialy deadly. Tuning an proper welding tecniques are required here.
      Besides having pasts failiure due to improper welds or inferior metal there are also things like snap oversteer and bind unloading (don't know proper term) that can cause someone to loose control on a high speed bump.
      Having worked in a performance shop for several years I have seen and heard horror stories of do it yourselfers dying or getting very close to dying. One guy with a home made R&P set up, his cheap steering shaft set up consisting of 3 u-joints broke free during a high speed jaunt due to an inadequate design, potentialy deadly for others since he was on the highway and hit a pot hole. Another guy, with a home made four link lost control when his home made lower link to frame bracket broke loose during a panic stop situation. This was caused by metal fatigue due to exsessive heat from his gas and stick welder.I asked him why he didn't have a safety plate to secure the lower link if the spherical were to break...his answer " I didn't know I needed one, there wasn't one in the picture." This also happened on a public highway. Remember there are proper areas to test and not everyone here is going to do so.
      Ok to validate this post as something about truck arm suspensions Having riden in a 70 Chevelle equipt with a HTH truck are set up, I must say the system improved the car over stock. The most praise I have heard about this kit is its ease of adjustment.
      Last edited by MrQuick; 03-22-2005 at 09:44 AM. Reason: spell check please?
      MrQuick ΜΟΛ'ΩΝ ΛΑΒ'Ε


    8. #28
      Join Date
      Jan 2005
      Posts
      160
      Norm,

      You're right you need to be able to tune in a reasonable manner. Some guys will just never get it. Most here seem to be capable though.

      That plays in to what I think Quick is really saying too. I take for granted that you tune cars on a race track and not the street but that isn't the case for most I suppose. Point taken.

      I've seen some pretty stupidly fabricated things on race tracks too where cars are supposed to be inspected. I saw a car with a black pipe roll cage and a fiberglass racing seat. The guy got hit, rolled and broke his back. Now he's in a wheel chair.

      Life's a full contact sport and it is dangerous to a certain extent. No harm in warning others to be careful of unintended consequences, though.

      I was thinking about the truck arm too but like M69 said, I think a 3 link or torque arm is a better design overall (less compromises). I'm going the torque arm route. I'm putting a lot of thought into LCA length though. I'm not sure how I'll get the mounts moved forward yet but it seems worth doing. However, this starts to be part of the problem that I had with the truck arm design to begin with (too long, no floor pan clearance for a lowered car). More compromises.....


      Wally

    9. #29
      Join Date
      Aug 2004
      Location
      Greenville, IL
      Posts
      262
      Country Flag: United States

      Beginning setup

      Start there but give yourself plenty of adjustment on the PHB up and down. (I would say mostly up from there but my experience is with dirt cars so don't go by my word on that part.) This isn't a two hole sort of adjustment situation. I like the infinitely adjustable slotted mounts. They'll give you several inches. Again, you can get them from all of the stockcar suppliers.
      So w/ the arm mounts as low as I can get them, the phb just above the virtual intersect point and parallel to the rearend when it is in the middle of its adjustability. I would be at a good starting point, correct?

      What about the spring and shock locations? I was trying to decide wether to mount the springs on the axle or on the arms, what would be better. Remember, I am using a 9" so the perches are not already on the rearend. As far as the shocks go, I have seen them mounted on the tail end of the arms. Is this a good location?

    10. #30
      Join Date
      Jan 2005
      Posts
      160
      Any of those mounting scenarios should be fine. You'll just have to figure your spring rate based on whatever motion ratio you end up with for your mounting application. Same thing for shocks.



      Wally

    11. #31
      Join Date
      Aug 2004
      Posts
      223
      Quote Originally Posted by MrQuick
      Having riden in a 70 Chevelle equipt with a HTH truck are set up, I must say the system improved the car over stock. The most praise I have heard about this kit is its ease of adjustment[/I].
      My '69 chevelle has the HTH kit, I have done a little tinkering with tuning it. It does have a couple of different holes for the attachement of the truckarms, although 9 times out of 10 you'd use the bottom holes. I can tweak the panhard rod and spring jacks literally in just a couple of minutes. I have the panhard set basically level when the car is at rest, with the length adjusted to center the rearend under the car. Adjusting the rear springs is just a matter of sticking a 1/2" drive rachet in the trunk and turning it. I don't have any quantitative data, my 'tuning' was all seat of the pants, but it's definitely easy to do. I found that if I had the rear too high the car felt floaty when I turned and too lively over bumps. Too low, it felt kinda 'dead' like the rear suspension was kind of inhibited from moving freely. In the right spot it feels neutral and smooth through corners and just as the HTH guys have said in other posts, the more throttle you give it the more it digs in and holds. When you do exceed the traction limit it does so predictibly.
      I posted an autocross review with the setup a while back, do a search. Cliff notes: the car was much better than stock and performed well, but I could still tell I was driving a big, heavy, 40 year old car.

      One dissagreeable behavior I've noticed, although this is present to some extent with any live axle setup with a pretty stiff suspension, if you hit bumps mid-corner it can be unsettling. The entire rear of the car may jump to one side or the other slightly. I had this behavior with my 4th gen camaro too though, but it wasn't quite as pronounced as with the chevelle. It definitely behaves better on smooth pavement.

      If you went to the track with a 1/2" rachet, a couple of big sockets, 1 wrench, a tape measure, and a pair of channel-locks, you can tune the HTH kit without raising the car off the ground. It would take you maybe 3-4 minutes between runs.

    12. #32
      Join Date
      Aug 2004
      Posts
      957
      One dissagreeable behavior I've noticed, although this is present to some extent with any live axle setup with a pretty stiff suspension, if you hit bumps mid-corner it can be unsettling. The entire rear of the car may jump to one side or the other slightly.
      Do you know what spring rate you are running on the car? I concur, it is not too fun when the car scampers about in a turn, but you might be able to mitigate this somewhat by running a softer spring. If your car doesn't bottom out over bumps, you may able to soften things up a bit, just look at what the free height of the spring is, and contact Coleman or some of the other circle track suppliers. Might be worth a try. I read another post where the guy who had the car felt it was a bit stiff, he also didn't like the noise associated with the setup. I have no clue about the HTH guys, but folks seems to over-spring cars a lot of the times. BTW, the setup doesn't run an anti-sway bar, does it?

      And by the way, short of hard numbers, the ass-o-meter is a usually good indicator of performance, if you are honest (which is clearly the case with your description above). Thanks for the feedback!

      Mark

    13. #33
      Join Date
      Aug 2004
      Posts
      223
      Mean 69, I have no idea what the spring rates are, they are the ones that come with the kit, and I have the front ones to match. The Carrera shocks they send with the kit are supposedly matched to the springs. There is no rear sway bar, and I run the stock sway bar on the front. The car doesn't feel too stiff to me in general, it just has some little gremlins that show up when you hit a bump .

      I replied in the 'noise' thread too, the panhard has heim joints and is connected to a heavy bracket that is welded to the frame of the car, so some noise is not a surprise, especially for me since I'm running poly body mounts.

    Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 1 2



    Advertise on Pro-Touring.com