Enter your username:
Do you want to login or register?
  • Forgot your password?

    Login / Register




    Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast
    Results 1 to 20 of 28

    Hybrid View

    1. #1
      Join Date
      Oct 2007
      Location
      Dallas, TX
      Posts
      45

      Where's the money?

      I'm 22 and have been in the automotive industry since I was 15, started detailing cars now I'm a full blown painter. I'm going to finish my AAS in Auto Body Technology in May "08 and then hope to start the AAS in Automotive Technology for the mechanical part then a Bachelors in Automotive Engineering. I've been in a few body shops over the last couple years and am getting tired of the idiots that work in this industry and they're in every shop big or small. Is it like that everywhere or is there a shop somewhere where they do things right and people really care about what they're doing, not just screwing customers and techs? I hate almost all estimators because they do nothing but lie to customers and insurance companies and try to screw techs every chance they get. I'm sure every industry has these problems but in the body shop business it seems like that's the standard way of doing business, and I don't want to be part of that much longer as I'm honest and enjoy my work, but due to the idiots who don't care it makes it harder on the few who do. What aspects of the auto industry make the most money? Sales, mechanical, contract work, motorsports, finance, warranty, special interest, welding, chassis, engine/ transmission building, parts? I'm very exact/ precise, organized and detailed. Some opinions would be appreciated from those with experience.



    2. #2
      Join Date
      Sep 2007
      Location
      Elizabeth City NC
      Posts
      233
      reading this It looks like something I would write even starting out as a detailer, but I think you are right about most all you wrote no matter where you go there are going to be estimators that want things done for as cheap as possible but that is there job. managers at the shops are the ones that need to set that straight but the whole insurance body shop business is kinda a no win situation, Im gonna stick with it for a while longer but from what I have experienced most are as you stated. In this area I cant make the money Im making unless Im in some form of management or medical field, I will say the independent shops are looking more apealing than the dealerships around just because of the BS. If you can put up with some than it is a good field to stay in.
      67 camaro

    3. #3
      Join Date
      Nov 2007
      Location
      Portland, OR
      Posts
      36
      I've worked in a variety of manufacturing and automotive settings, and can tell you this from my experience.

      First, auto body shops are the worst. I'm sure some are better than others, and some are probably even great. But in general body shops have the most BS and the most dishonesty of any part of the industry that I've been exposed to.

      Second, -and this is something I've recently learned- you have have to decide what kind of an employer you want. Big dealerships, and big shops will usually pay a moderatley skilled worker better than a small shop. When I was a machinist for a big manufacturer I made a LOT more money then when I came to work where I am now.

      But there are a few things that I totally like about the small shop atmosphere. The most important is that you can learn sooooo much more. Instead of focusing on one thing, I get to hop all over the place, and work with some really skilled guys. They want to see me succeed because my work affects the quality of their product too. The other nice thing is that there is no politics or any other BS. We all work together, and we all know what's going on. We don't keep the customer in the dark, and they can tell. The last thing that I like about a small shop, is that there is a lot of room for advancement (think no salary cap). If you have the skill, there is no reason you can't make much more money building cars in a small shop then you will at a dealership or other large employer.

    4. #4
      Join Date
      Jun 2005
      Location
      San Mateo,Ca
      Posts
      45
      The best way to avoid these kinds of headaches is to either be top dog, as in your own shop. This way you can run it your way.Or,be a worker bee and let the boss decied if he wants to deal with those kinds of people.It also helps if your the best worker bee at that shop.Which will eventually lead to you wanting your own shop.Twisted isn't it.

    5. #5
      Join Date
      Nov 2007
      Location
      Portland, OR
      Posts
      36
      Quote Originally Posted by romar 02 SS
      The best way to avoid these kinds of headaches is to either be top dog, as in your own shop. This way you can run it your way.Or,be a worker bee and let the boss decied if he wants to deal with those kinds of people.It also helps if your the best worker bee at that shop.Which will eventually lead to you wanting your own shop.Twisted isn't it.
      /\/\/\/\/\/\/\

      There's a lot of truth in that. But not everyone want's to (or can) deal with customers and employees. Also, we all gotta start somewhere!

    6. #6
      Join Date
      Aug 2004
      Location
      Portland,Oregon
      Posts
      599
      Quote Originally Posted by Nate_ERC
      The last thing that I like about a small shop, is that there is a lot of room for advancement (think no salary cap). If you have the skill, there is no reason you can't make much more money building cars in a small shop then you will at a dealership or other large employer.
      I'm going to have to disagree with you on that.

      A smaller shop usually can't pay what the bigger shops can.
      Small shop can't take on as many projects as the bigger shops.

      As far as the no salary cap at a smaller shop, There most certainly is. How can the workers salary keep going up with no cap? The shop needs to make a certain amount and the workers salary need to be way below it so the shop rate covers overhead and a profit.
      If I'm way off. I'd like an explanation or your point of view on it.
      Robert Braga
      1969 Camaro LS2/T56 D1SC
      www.automotivedesigneng.com
      US Collision / Mortenson's Custom Touch / DPE Wheel / Tim Bruning / Columbia Parts Company

    7. #7
      Join Date
      Oct 2007
      Location
      Dallas, TX
      Posts
      45
      I was seriously considering going for a BS in Mechanical Engineering, but after looking at the coursework they take.....math wasn't my strongest subject in high school. Plus it would take a minimum 4 years maybe longer, plus I'm not the type to be in an office all day long. How much do mechanical engineers make on average? I heard welders make bank as well, or do they?

    8. #8
      Join Date
      Apr 2005
      Location
      Los Angeles
      Posts
      352
      Quote Originally Posted by theoriginator
      I was seriously considering going for a BS in Mechanical Engineering, but after looking at the coursework they take.....math wasn't my strongest subject in high school. Plus it would take a minimum 4 years maybe longer, plus I'm not the type to be in an office all day long. How much do mechanical engineers make on average? I heard welders make bank as well, or do they?
      if you do well in school I can quote you what my friend told me about 2 years ago for Rockedyne, Pratt & Whittney (they do space shuttle engines and stuff like that) straight outta college they were paying $55k for a B.S. in engineering with no experiance. and $72k for M.S. in Engineering. Imagine what they guys make in 10 years time.

      Being in an office or not is up to you.

      What part of Automotive Engineering WON'T need math?? Math in the end is just practice. I'm taking "Kinematics of Machines" a prerequistie for a auto suspension class and its insane math. If you want to avoid math the "technology" programs don't use calculus and everything is watered down. Its up to you how much you really want to know what's going on with your car. The younger you start, the better you are. I'm 29 and freaken burned out. I'm about to finish my masters. I wish i did Mechancial Engineering first. I did Manufacturing Engineering which is more the business/facilities side of things. I'm about to finish Engineering Management. I dunno if i said already.. and lookign at Mechancial Masters for the automotive classes they have.

      check this thing out for salaries:
      http://www.cbsalary.com/
      -Tas
      '04 Mustang Saleen sc281 speedster
      '67 Mustang notchback: The fabled $500 non running project car: 308, auto, 2 barrel (now 4), AC(now removed), 5 lug, disk front, drum rear, power brakes and steering... that I got started and home for $65 :D

    9. #9
      Join Date
      Nov 2007
      Location
      Portland, OR
      Posts
      36
      Quote Originally Posted by 96Z28SS
      I'm going to have to disagree with you on that.

      A smaller shop usually can't pay what the bigger shops can.
      Small shop can't take on as many projects as the bigger shops.

      As far as the no salary cap at a smaller shop, There most certainly is. How can the workers salary keep going up with no cap? The shop needs to make a certain amount and the workers salary need to be way below it so the shop rate covers overhead and a profit.
      If I'm way off. I'd like an explanation or your point of view on it.
      You are right. But I came from a uninon shop originally, where pay scale was determined by how long you'd been there, and then capped out after two years. In this industry you are (hopefully) payed for your skill. While they are few and far between, I do know several guys who make just a couple bucks under the shop's hourly rate. It's worth not making any money off of them, because of the reputation guys like that can bring to your shop.

      I like the variety, and room for advancement. There's no contract saying that all 2+ year machinists make 24.00, and all 2+ year welders make 20.00, etc...

    10. #10
      Join Date
      Aug 2004
      Location
      Portland,Oregon
      Posts
      599
      Quote Originally Posted by Nate_ERC
      I do know several guys who make just a couple bucks under the shop's hourly rate. It's worth not making any money off of them, because of the reputation guys like that can bring to your shop.
      I don't know many shops that can do that. I can see bring on a certain person that might have very high skills for a short period of time to get something done where that shop might not have a guy with that skill level. I couldn't see having him permanently just under the shop rate.
      Robert Braga
      1969 Camaro LS2/T56 D1SC
      www.automotivedesigneng.com
      US Collision / Mortenson's Custom Touch / DPE Wheel / Tim Bruning / Columbia Parts Company

    11. #11
      Join Date
      Feb 2005
      Location
      Cape Cod Mass.
      Posts
      245
      I think it's hard to find big shops that have alot of pride in their work most have to much going on.I ran a small family repair buisiness for a few years and can tell you its not easy finding help that really cares about their work , there are some and when we found one we took good care of them!! Owning your own biz can be very rewarding but also alot to handle. I'd look around alot there are people who will pay good for someone who has pride in thier work , and thats in any part on the auto field. Look in the part that you like most!!
      NOW WHAT??? lol

    12. #12
      Join Date
      Jan 2006
      Posts
      464
      If you want to move to cali and your the right fit for our shop, we are looking to expand to on site paint with in the year. We are tired of trying to find some one to put in the same effort we do in fabrication into their paint work, so we are going to do it on site.

      [email protected]

      Rodger

    13. #13
      Join Date
      Mar 2007
      Posts
      18
      I wish I could find a shop like that in my area.
      67 Chevelle 283 auto, soon to be on 18's w/ a TKO

      (Eventually will be a low compression 496 with a procharger)

      38 Ford Tudor Sedan-- project car

      1996 Dodge 3500 Dually, 12V cummins
      1994 F150XL rollin w/ the mean buzzin half dozen

    14. #14
      Join Date
      Aug 2004
      Location
      CHICAGO SUBURBS
      Posts
      761
      I learned body work at one of the best shops around this area. I moved on, and couldn't find anyone doing anything but butchery, and theivery. I no longer work for a bodyshop!

    15. #15
      Join Date
      Mar 2005
      Location
      NY
      Posts
      1,097
      I've known finance guys that cleared $300,000+ per year. But if you're honest, unless you're in a dealership with high sales numbers, it's doubtfull you'll see that kind of money.
      The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few.

    16. #16
      Join Date
      Sep 2006
      Location
      Southern Indiana
      Posts
      4,709
      Country Flag: United States
      Try being a diag tech and electrical specialist and a perfectionist. I also build race engines on the thinnest budgets around (but still strong and make power)I went from working at a Firestone mastercare (fired for something I didnt do) got a 9 dollar a flat rate hour raise but lost my guranteeed minimum,,,,but right now have to deal with a 25 yr old punk service manager.
      $23 a flat rate hour sounds great till you only clear 25 to 30 hours in 2 weeks.
      Got fed the well you can turn 60 to a 100 hours a two week period,, yeah right only if you live at the shop.
      The boss wants a guy to come in at 530 to 6 am and stay till 8 or 9 pm, sorry I dont have enough work as it is.
      to make a staement but less than $15k since march ,,,makes me STARVING and I am having to buy more tools to use as my job duties and direction have changed.
      I get the crap jobs and have to fix the ones that take 12 hours and pay 2.
      So I am looking around for a better job or one atleast not as far away (about 40 miles oneway).

    17. #17
      Join Date
      Apr 2005
      Location
      Los Angeles
      Posts
      352
      I think you'd be better off going straight to a BS in Mechanical Engineering with an Automotive focus (It will take long enough without putting other schooling before it.) That way you're more well rounded.

      I'm about to take over a machine shop and I'm going to try to gear it more towards automotive(if I can) while still doing some top money aerospace stuff. The main thing is to love what you're doing. Even if you do something that's not your hobby, its still fun for engineers to solve all kinds of problems, even if its not automotive.
      -Tas
      '04 Mustang Saleen sc281 speedster
      '67 Mustang notchback: The fabled $500 non running project car: 308, auto, 2 barrel (now 4), AC(now removed), 5 lug, disk front, drum rear, power brakes and steering... that I got started and home for $65 :D

    18. #18
      Join Date
      Feb 2003
      Location
      Houston, TX
      Posts
      3,446
      Country Flag: United States
      Quote Originally Posted by THX 138
      I think you'd be better off going straight to a BS in Mechanical Engineering with an Automotive focus (It will take long enough without putting other schooling before it.) That way you're more well rounded.
      Agreed. Then get a job in the oil/gas business here in Texas and you will have your six-figure job in no time. Then you can build cars as a hobby and sell them when you are done. That is what I do

      Tony
      Co-Founder, LS1TECH.com


      Forged Wheel Dealer, Contact me for a quote!
      www.DV8Motoring.com

    19. #19
      Join Date
      Mar 2005
      Location
      Miamisburg, Oh
      Posts
      2,396
      Oh, and he happens to run a large car-geek website also. ;) that helps keep the money flowing. lol.

    20. #20
      Join Date
      Feb 2003
      Location
      Houston, TX
      Posts
      3,446
      Country Flag: United States
      Any engineering degree requires intensive math. I wasn't the best at calculus in high school either, but I just studied harder and practiced solving problems in college to get where I needed to be.

      In the oil/gas industry we typically hire fresh eng grads with zero experience at around $55-60K, plus around $10K annual bonus. Not bad for zero experience. In 7-8 yrs you will be well into the 100K plus range.

      Funny you mentioned welding, I put myself through college as a welder and pipe fitter. Working in an office is 100000x better than sweating my ass off in nomex coveralls and hardhat in 95F Houston temps. ;)

      I get my share of grease in the garage when I get home.
      Co-Founder, LS1TECH.com


      Forged Wheel Dealer, Contact me for a quote!
      www.DV8Motoring.com

    Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast



    Advertise on Pro-Touring.com