Enter your username:
Do you want to login or register?
  • Forgot your password?

    Login / Register




    Page 3 of 3 FirstFirst 1 2 3
    Results 41 to 49 of 49
    1. #41
      Join Date
      Nov 2002
      Location
      state of confusion
      Posts
      1,499
      Country Flag: United States
      74/26 may be the roll couple distribution, but the effects of roll center heights and unsprung mass (at axle height) also enter into this, and those other two are significantly rearward-biased. I'm given to believe that you want the total lateral load distribution, which considers all of those factors, to be slightly more front-biased than the weight distribution. At least for a FE/RWD/stick axle car. Maybe a total lateral load distribution of 58/42 for a car with 53/47 weight distribution, or 55ish/45ish for a 50/50 weight?

      Simplified, chassis torsional stiffness is a spring in series with the suspension roll stiffnesses. I'm sure that that 74/26 value is a theoretical one based on a completely rigid chassis and the sprung mass taken as a single lump at the CG. In actuality, the roll moment distribution will vary from that depending on mass distribution, locations of discrete lumped masses, and variations in chassis stiffness over its length. Less simply, I think it's part of an overall parallel-series combination of springs and masses, but that gets really complex in a hurry.

      Seems to me that with less front end weight, you wouldn't need to drag quite as much LLT forward, and could perhaps be satisfied with a slightly softer chassis. But that's using a pretty sharp pencil, and I doubt that you could actually end up with a chassis whose stiffness differs by some "precisely calculated" amount from a value that you don't really know in the first place. The better solution still is to build it stiff and work with the springs/shocks/sta-bars for the tuning.




      Norm
      '08 GT coupe, 5M, suspension unstockish (the occasional track toy)
      '19 WRX, Turbo-H4/6M (the family sedan . . . seriously)
      Gone but not forgotten dep't:
      '01 Maxima 20AE 5M, '10 LGT 6M, '95 626, V6/5M; '79 Malibu, V8/4M-5M; '87 Maxima, V6/5M; '72 Pinto, I4/4M; '64 Dodge V8/3A


    2. #42
      Join Date
      Apr 2001
      Location
      Central CA USA
      Posts
      6,114
      Country Flag: United States
      Norm,
      Thanks for pointing that out, I didn't think of it.
      This Camaro has 60% rear RLLD, I had to go look it up, but it's software generated (Perf Trends) and I don't have full confidence in it since it predicts mild to heavy oversteer and we have understeer.

      Here's our car running with no rear anti roll bar as a test, it had heavy understeer. Notice also the LR tire is very lightly loaded too. Since the rear is not stiff enough to carry it's proper cornering load, the front has to carry it. That was enough extra load to lift the inside wheel Acceleration forces were probably involved too. Anyway, the chassis get's pretty high loads on it when doing things like this, and the stiffer it is the better. If the subframe is flexing, then the fenders are too, pretty hard on the body. We are seeing some cracks at the upper rear side window corners. Which is very common on this model.
      Last edited by David Pozzi; 10-14-2007 at 10:38 AM.
      67 Camaro RS that will be faster than anything Mary owns.

    3. #43
      Join Date
      Jun 2005
      Posts
      379
      Quote Originally Posted by Damn True
      So David,

      Am I correct in assuming from the above that since my car will be lighter in the front by virtue of an aluminum block and a bunch of fiberglass that my weight distribution is likely to be closer to 50/50 and therefore I will be needing a relatively stiffer chassis?

      Good thing I am planning an 8pt (maybe 10) cage.
      Be carefull in assumming that installing a cage is going to stiffen the chassis in a way that you want it to.

      By design, a cages main purpose is to protect the passenger, not reinforce the chassis.

      Most of the torsional loads (in the front) transmit from the front frame rails to the cowl to the "A" pillars to the roof structure.

      To stiffen the structure the "cage" needs to transmit the loads from the front frame rails (at the suspension mounting point) to the cowl structure and then to the "A" pillars and the roof structure. If the cage is just attached to the front and rear of the rockers, and then the rear frame rails and spring mounting point it will be floating inside the roof structure. Even if you go through the firewall to the front frame rails, doing so without attaching the cage to the cowl and "A" pillars will not help as much as you would like. Also attaching the halo to the roof above the windshield and the side glass will help considerably, but this is difficult if you are planning on installing the factory head liner.

      PS: If your weight distribution is closser to 50/50 I believe that you can get by with a weaker chassis than you could if your distribution were 80/20.

    4. #44
      Join Date
      Jun 2005
      Posts
      379
      Quote Originally Posted by David Pozzi
      SNIP...

      Here's our car running with no rear anti roll bar as a test, it had heavy understeer. Notice also the LR tire is very lightly loaded too. Since the rear is not stiff enough to carry it's proper cornering load, the front has to carry it. That was enough extra load to lift the inside wheel Acceleration forces were probably involved too. Anyway, the chassis get's pretty high loads on it when doing things like this, and the stiffer it is the better. If the subframe is flexing, then the fenders are too, pretty hard on the body. We are seeing some cracks at the upper rear side window corners. Which is very common on this model.
      Hi Dave,

      Is the gap between the door and fender typically like that (it looks much tighter at the top than at the bottom) or is that a result of chassis twist / flex???

    5. #45
      Join Date
      Jun 2005
      Posts
      379
      Speeking about application specific rear suspensions, here is the rear suspension we are currently building for our 66 mustang project car.





      This is for a street, strip application. The components are designed for relativly high HP (1,100 HP, 1,000 FPT) and relativly high shock loads. Light springs, heavy sway bar, etc...

      All of the chassis mods we have made are most likely counter to the typical drag race way of thinking, but we are also concerned with driveability on the street. Also, I believe that the weight we added to the car by reinforcing the chassis, will help transfer the power to the ground better than one that was left stock.

    6. #46
      Join Date
      Jul 2005
      Location
      Mountain View, CA
      Posts
      9,583
      Country Flag: United States
      Quote Originally Posted by SN65
      Be carefull in assumming that installing a cage is going to stiffen the chassis in a way that you want it to.

      By design, a cages main purpose is to protect the passenger, not reinforce the chassis.
      It's not an assumption. The guy that will build my cage builds SCCA compliant cages every day for Porsche's, BMW's, Miata's, Corvette's, and has built a number of quality endurance racing cars as well. He isn't experimenting, he knows what he is doing.

      Quote Originally Posted by SN65
      Most of the torsional loads (in the front) transmit from the front frame rails to the cowl to the "A" pillars to the roof structure.

      To stiffen the structure the "cage" needs to transmit the loads from the front frame rails (at the suspension mounting point) to the cowl structure and then to the "A" pillars and the roof structure. If the cage is just attached to the front and rear of the rockers, and then the rear frame rails and spring mounting point it will be floating inside the roof structure. Even if you go through the firewall to the front frame rails, doing so without attaching the cage to the cowl and "A" pillars will not help as much as you would like. Also attaching the halo to the roof above the windshield and the side glass will help considerably, but this is difficult if you are planning on installing the factory head liner.
      We have that covered I assure you.

      Quote Originally Posted by SN65
      PS: If your weight distribution is closser to 50/50 I believe that you can get by with a weaker chassis than you could if your distribution were 80/20.
      That seems 180 degrees out from what David said above. What is your "belief" based on?
      True T.

      Whats new with Project 1/2-Trak?


      Follow my wisecracks on Sports, Food, Politics and other BS on Twitter.

      My blog

      When they kick out your front door, How you gonna come?
      With your hands on your head, Or on the trigger of your gun?

    7. #47
      Join Date
      Apr 2001
      Location
      Central CA USA
      Posts
      6,114
      Country Flag: United States
      Quote Originally Posted by SN65
      Hi Dave,

      Is the gap between the door and fender typically like that (it looks much tighter at the top than at the bottom) or is that a result of chassis twist / flex???
      It's like that sitting still, and I believe it was that way before we started autocrossing it.


      On the subject of a cage helping torsional stiffness. I tested our 69 camaro with a Trans Am spec cage, it has forward reaching bars off the vertical bar near the A pillars through the firewall that attach just behind the steering box on the frame rail kickup.

      As far as I can tell, the cage in this car does NOTHING for torsional rigidity. I WAS SHOCKED, IT WAS TERRIBLE. The car had no extra braces to the sub other than the front braces. SCCA did not allow the cage to connect to the subframe except for the forward two braces. There really is no triangulation with this setup.

      Full tube chassis cars were not allowed in Trans Am in the time this car was built. The main hoops of the cage were not allowed to connect to the subframe. A proper diagonal brace structure should do a lot to stiffen the chassis.

      True,
      I do think a Camaro with closer to 50/50 would have less torsion load. As weight bias shifts from front to rear, the roll couple would shift to the rear too. My Lola has almost the reverse of my Camaro in roll couple distribution.
      David
      Last edited by David Pozzi; 10-18-2007 at 05:20 PM.
      67 Camaro RS that will be faster than anything Mary owns.

    8. #48
      Join Date
      Apr 2005
      Location
      Colorado Springs
      Posts
      761
      Quote Originally Posted by SN65
      PS: If your weight distribution is closser to 50/50 I believe that you can get by with a weaker chassis than you could if your distribution were 80/20.
      I don't know that I'd say you could get by with a weaker chassis. Rigidity yields benefits regardless of weight distribution. Now your roll couple percentages would be radically different. As a matter of fact, in a front engine, RWD chassis, your front roll couple percentage should be going up as your weight percentage moves back if you want to maintain neutral handling.

      David's Gen 2 Camaro with 74% roll couple with 56% front weight bias is smack dab in the middle of the theoretical neutral handling line. A car with 50/50 distribution would be closer to 86% front roll couple.

    9. #49
      Join Date
      Jun 2005
      Posts
      379
      Quote Originally Posted by Damn True
      It's not an assumption. The guy that will build my cage builds SCCA compliant cages every day for Porsche's, BMW's, Miata's, Corvette's, and has built a number of quality endurance racing cars as well. He isn't experimenting, he knows what he is doing.

      We have that covered I assure you.

      That seems 180 degrees out from what David said above. What is your "belief" based on?
      I am sure that your "guy" knows what he is doing. Building cages that are SCCA compliant takes a great deal of knowledge and expertise.

      I have not read the SCCA rulebook in regard to cages, but, if it is anything like the NHRA rulebook, it covers all of the safety issued and nothing more.

      So, unless the cage is something more than a typical 8 or 10 point safety cage, it will do little to nothing in regard to the torsional stiffness of your particular chassis.

      With that said, you mentioned that you are attaching the upper structure of the roof and cage together. Have you decided on the type of gussets and their attachments yet? Instead of the typical gusset, maybe you would consider a 10 or 12 gage plate with the free edge reinforced with a 1/2" diameter tube.

      In regard to my belief that a chassis can be less stiff as the weight distribution becomes more and more even. Maybe I am wrong. I tend to look at things from a structural steel point of view. In that world, structures become less complex as the loads become more uniform.

    Page 3 of 3 FirstFirst 1 2 3



    Advertise on Pro-Touring.com