Enter your username:
Do you want to login or register?
  • Forgot your password?

    Login / Register




    Results 1 to 20 of 25

    Hybrid View

    1. #1
      Join Date
      Aug 2004
      Posts
      830
      ....a roll cage on top of that tube is what gives is the torsional strength, the rec. tube gives you the beam strength you need



    2. #2
      Join Date
      Jan 2005
      Location
      Tomball, TX
      Posts
      438
      Country Flag: United States
      I'm not sure which one you're talking about:
      1. Which material has better torsion resistance when you're just looking at a simple fixed beam undergoing torsion, or
      2. Which one will give you higher overall rigidity from your rollcage as a whole

      If you're talking about which cross section resists torsion better (topic number 1), that can be found using the polar moment of inertia of each of their cross sections. The higher the polar moment of inertia, the more resistant it is to torsional stress.

      You didn't say whether you were referring to 2" diameter of 4" diameter, so I calculated both. For the circular cross section, the polar moment of inertia is given by:

      2" Diameter
      J = 1/32 * pi * diam^4
      = 1/32 * pi * (2 in)^4
      J = 1.57 in^4

      4" Diameter
      J = 1/32 * pi * diam^4
      = 1/32 * pi * (4 in)^4
      J = 25.13 in^4

      Since I wasn't sure which kind of cross section you were talking about, I did it for all 3. For the rectangular cross section:

      2" x 4"
      J = 1/12 * b * h * (b^2 + h^2)
      = 1/12 * (2) * (4) * [ (2)^2 + (4)^2 ]
      J = 13.33 in^4

      2" x 2"
      J = 1/12 * b * h * (b^2 + h^2)
      = 1/12 * (2) * (2) * [ (2)^2 + (2)^2 ]
      J = 2.67 in^4

      4" x 4"
      J = 1/12 * b * h * (b^2 + h^2)
      = 1/12 * (4) * (4) * [ (4)^2 + (4)^2 ]
      J = 42.67 in^4


      As for which one will give you a higher overall rigidity of your rollcage as a whole (topic number 2), I know very little about rollcage design and have never done any of it myself. Having said that, my guess would be that it will depend more on the design of the rollcage than the type of material used to construct it. If I had to guess, I would say that most of the stress seen by the individual beams in a rollcage is going to be of either an axial (tension/compression) or bending nature rather than strict torsion. But again, I don't know that, that's just what my instinct would tell me. Anyways, I hope that helps. And someone please correct me if I screwed up those calcs somewhere...it's been a while since I was in Mechanics of Materials.
      Ryan
      '68 Camaro (slowly coming back together...very slowly)

    3. #3
      Join Date
      Apr 2005
      Posts
      21
      well I was thinking figuring out what would be torsionally stronger, chassis wise. I don't think rectangular tubing would work to well as a rollcage though

    4. #4
      Join Date
      Nov 2005
      Location
      Auburn, WA
      Posts
      1,359
      Deepblue68, your calculations are incorrect. You need to subtract the PMOI for the hollow sections, since we are talking about hollow tubes. You can compare round tubes in the manner which you did, but not round to non-circular.

      The 4" tube will be more rigid for a given length. But for the manner in which you are talking about, it's all a wash. For a flat plane (chassis), I'd use rectangular tube for it's good torsional rigidity (4" tube isn't very practical) and great bending strength, something which it tough to get with round tube. The torsional stiffness of a flat chassis is very limited.

      Now, if you triangulate the chassis (with a cage or similar), then it's a whole different ballgame.
      Matt Jones
      Mechanical Engineer
      Art Morrison Enterprises

    5. #5
      Join Date
      Apr 2005
      Posts
      21
      yeah I am going to put a cage on it as well

    6. #6
      Join Date
      Jan 2005
      Location
      Tomball, TX
      Posts
      438
      Country Flag: United States
      Quote Originally Posted by silver69camaro
      Deepblue68, your calculations are incorrect. You need to subtract the PMOI for the hollow sections, since we are talking about hollow tubes. You can compare round tubes in the manner which you did, but not round to non-circular.
      Oh, wow, I guess that's what I get for trying to do those calculations during a 6 hour study binge for a Controls exam I had this morning. Geez, that's pretty said I forgot to subtract the hollow sections out. Anyway, thanks for the correction. Am I anywhere close in thinking that most of the stress seen by members of a rollcage is either axial or bending (vs. torsion)?

      Also, you're saying you can't directly compare the polar moment of inertia of a rectangular cross-section to that of a circular cross-section?
      Ryan
      '68 Camaro (slowly coming back together...very slowly)

    7. #7
      Join Date
      Nov 2005
      Location
      Auburn, WA
      Posts
      1,359
      Quote Originally Posted by DeepBlue68
      Wait, you're saying you can't compare the polar moment of inertia of a rectangular cross-section to that of a circular cross-section?
      If you don't subtract the PMOI for the hollow sections, then no you can't. Once the hollow areas are accounted for, then the two numbers can be compared.
      Matt Jones
      Mechanical Engineer
      Art Morrison Enterprises

    8. #8
      Join Date
      Nov 2005
      Location
      Auburn, WA
      Posts
      1,359
      Quote Originally Posted by DeepBlue68
      Am I anywhere close in thinking that most of the stress seen by members of a rollcage is either axial or bending (vs. torsion)?
      To update my post to your updated post...

      When I design cages, I deal mostly with direct forces, and columnar bending with longer bars. There is some torsional issues that you can think about, but honestly, I let FEA do the work on that.

      When you twist a roll cage, most of the forces are primarily axial like you mentioned. Very well designed cages exhibit the most direct tension and compression forces (obviously it's stiffer that way), instead of weird moments and bending forces at the joints.
      Matt Jones
      Mechanical Engineer
      Art Morrison Enterprises

    9. #9
      Join Date
      Jan 2005
      Location
      Tomball, TX
      Posts
      438
      Country Flag: United States
      Cool...what FEA program do you use? We've learned on NE Nastran here at school, and to be honest I'm not a huge fan of it. I've heard from more than one person that I've interviewed with that it's not the best or the easiest to master, and there's better FEA programs around. Your thoughts?
      Ryan
      '68 Camaro (slowly coming back together...very slowly)




    Advertise on Pro-Touring.com