Enter your username:
Do you want to login or register?
  • Forgot your password?

    Login / Register




    Results 1 to 1 of 1
    1. #1
      Join Date
      Mar 2017
      Location
      Des Moines, IA
      Posts
      2
      Country Flag: United States

      Cooling Questions answered without BS

      I am not generally a big internet form guy but after reading some of the questions I thought I would extend cooling help to anyone that needs it. I read through several posts and there is some information that is a little crazy.

      Here is a peak at the draft of a cooling article I wrote for Car Craft, I think it will help and it is based on solid engineering principals.....

      Cooling Article
      How do I cool my engine? Good question, so how does an engine really cool? To really understand this you must figure out what that question really means.
      The whole cooling system is pretty basic. There are some different parts to the cooling system but before we dig in to those parts let’s talk about what we are trying to cool.
      There are really 3 major sources of heat and getting that heat transferred and away from the vehicle is the key to cooling success in a typical automotive application.

      Let’s discuss the heat sources:

      I assume that the reader has a basic comprehension that an engine is an air pump but just in case here is a quick lesson. The air pump (engine) is ran by firing a fuel source and that fuel source explodes and makes the pump run, power is measured by torque and horsepower is basically a calculation that is (RPM x Torque) / 5252 (radians per sec) = HP. Dynos do not measure horsepower, they measure torque and torque is what throws you into the back of your seat.
      Now that you have some basics, the explosion that makes your engine spin creates heat. Friction also creates some heat (most of it is in the valve train). This heat can be divided into more or less 3 main sources there are some other factors we can talk about that later.

      Radiated Heat-
      This is the heat that comes off the block and radiates off the exhaust, engine, and engine components. I have seen several vehicles with the exhaust so close to the firewall or floor that carpet would start to melt and paint would burn off the car. Due to vehicle design sometimes poor exhaust design can cause heating problems (radiated heat).
      Exhaust- Roughly 1/3 of an engines heat comes out the exhaust, the less restrictive and better the heat can get out without scorching your firewall and floorboards the better. More often poor exhaust design leads to comfort problems like hot feet and the floor of the car getting hot.
      Transferred Heat- This is the factor that really can be controlled, we must transfer heat from inside the engine away from the vehicle, in most vehicles this is done with a radiator. The radiator is really important because it transfers heat from the cooling system to the radiator (known as a heat exchanger) then the radiator pulls the heat out of the engine and transfers it away from the vehicle. The radiator can be made out of different materials, the better at heat transfer the better but we cannot run around with a 24K gold radiator (gold is a great heat conductor and does not corrode easy) so were more or less stuck with Copper and Aluminum.

      Radiator Construction

      Having a good radiator is like having a good foundation to your house, good high quality radiators can range from $500-2000+. Now before you freak out remember some people spend $10-20k+ on their engines, you need budget for your cooling system because it is extremely important. Most automotive radiators are made from aluminum. Aluminum radiators are light weight and lower cost than copper ones. Aluminum is not a better conductor of heat than copper however aluminum tubes can be made lighter and stronger allowing more surface area and you can build a radiator with bigger tubes without them expanding under pressure overcoming the efficiency differences.
      What’s the difference between a $150 radiator and a $2000 radiator? Pressure capability is the difference a high quality radiator like the PRC in the 67 C10 Car Craft project truck it can take pressure without failure. Why is that important? These radiators don’t leak, will survive more harsh conditions and let’s say you did have a head gasket issue most high quality radiators can take up to 50 PSI before having an issue meanwhile low cost import radiators will generally spring a leak or explode. Expensive aluminum radiators generally feature hand fabricated tanks, rugged mounting, larger capacity (more fluid to fin contact) and TIG welding. Lower cost radiators are MIG welded or have plastic tanks, are not rated for higher pressures and are weaker because the tubes and headers of the radiators are made from thinner material. Bottom line is you generally get what you pay for.

      Radiator Size
      (need to explain BTU’s and how to size a radiator)
      Good news is that most cars have a relatively well designed radiator location and the size is adequate for cruising around. However most cooling systems in muscle cars were designed for 200-300 hp max and you will need to increase the cooling capacity with a radiator that has more surface area and thermal capacity (Get rid of heat). Look at it this way if you swap engines in your car to one that makes twice the power you will need twice the cooling system. You’re not using your max horsepower when you are cruising and under 40 mph. You need more capacity when you are using the horsepower. NASCAR vs Dragster is a great example, with a NASCAR type car you need to cool 800-900 HP almost all of the time. With a dragster, it does a burn out, idles then does a pass for less than 15 seconds then idles again. There is a major difference in the cooling system. NASCAR also relies on oil cooling. Having an engine oil cooler is a great idea for high performance engines.

      Troubleshooting

      First don’t overlook the small things, pulleys, belts, thermostats, air dams that were factory installed
      Q: Car over heats when going under 40 but is fine on the highway
      A: You need more airflow through the radiator, that could mean a shroud, better movement of air through the engine compartment or add an electric fan vs the mechanical
      Q: Car overheats going above 40 mph
      A: You might need an air dam to force air into the radiator, might need better ducting to the radiator or you might need a radiator with more capacity.
      Q: Car overheats all the time
      A: Might need to look at the water pump, thermostat or you might need a complete cooling system overhaul

      Fans
      This is the part where I have the most knowledge. Fans move air, moving air across a radiator causes it to move heat and moving heat is what we need to do to cool the car. As I mentioned earlier about 1/3 of the cooling is radiated off the engine and its components having a fan moving air also helps the radiated cooling and the transferred cooling (radiator and oil cooler) of the engine and components. Having a good fan can help up to 2/3’s of the cooling so it is really important to have good air movement. In old days people used mechanical fans, there is nothing a matter with them except for you generally do not need a fan when you are going over 40 mph and the most stressed time of radiated and transferred cooling is when you are going at low speeds in hot weather. What makes a good electric fan? The motor and blade design of the cooling fan is most critical, materials are important because you do not want your fan to melt or to change shape if it gets hot. High-quality fans are made from glass filled nylon and are not shiny to the appearance, fans that are cheap and glossy looking are made from ABS plastic, and this plastic is not very durable in extreme conditions. High performance fans are not reversible due to the blade and motor design. Here are some basic steps to selecting a good fan.

      Specifications

      Does the fan manufacture show a data sheet for the fan that shows how the fan works under load? This measurement is generally called static pressure and is measured in inches of water in a column. These inches of water measurements represent the resistance in airflow. Some fans can move a bunch of air but when they are loaded with a radiator the fan blades cavitate air and the fan sits and spins and do not do much. These data sheets generally show airflow from 0” to when the fan blades cavitate, along with the airflow they generally show what happens to the current flow (power used) of the fan. If the fan manufacture cannot show you spec’s then they probably don’t make the fan or do not know what they are doing.

      Push Vs Pull

      Pulling air is generally 20% more efficient in real world applications. Why, it is easier to pull air through the radiator than push it, pushing air in a car application is generally a bad idea unless you cannot fit a puller fan or want to use it as auxiliary cooling for your air-conditioning. The other reason is that it blocks ram air from coming through the radiator making the frontal area of your heat exchanger smaller.

      Brushless Vs Brushed electric fan

      This is a new topic in the last few years as brushless fan motors are making their way into the aftermarket. In most automotive applications brushless fans are not needed. Brushless offers a few advantages but also come at a price in complexity and dollars. Most automotive fans last about 4,000-6,000 hours. Think of it like this 25 mph x 4,000 hours = 100,000 miles. There are long life brushed fans that can last as much as 20,000 hours these fans are designed for tractors, industrial vehicles and public transportation. Brushless fans have an increased life because there are no brushes to wear out manufactures claim up to 40,000 hours out of these designs and they are great for some applications.
      Pro’s- Brushless fans can integrate with CANBUS networks allowing for network installation in sophisticated applications, very long life, reduced current draw about 10-20% less current
      Con’s- Brushless fans will cost more than 3 times that of brushed fans, they have complex controllers. I looked online and SPAL’s 17” brushless fan has the same CFM as the GC cooling 16” BMF, Current draw is the same, SPAL is $695 GC Cooling is $200

      Overflow / puke tanks / expansion tanks

      This might be the biggest mistake made in the aftermarket, to be clear there are expansion tanks and over flow tanks, they are completely different. A good expansion tank holds about 2 quarts of fluid, the vehicle gets hot, pushes out air and steam into this tank and sucks back in fluid and continually tops its self. This is how modern systems work. The little billet catch can is not an expansion tank, I have spoken with numerous customers about this and it’s kind of like burping a baby, your engine will puke out of the tank unless it is allowed to expand and contract. This is dangerous because steam is hot and embarrassing if your car is puking up fluid too.

      Thermostats

      Check with your engine builder on this but use a thermostat and get one with the right temp for your application. Modern engines like to run between 195-210 degrees, there is some tolerance in thermostats 2-3% and the same with gauge sensors. I have literally helped customers that complained because there car is too hot when it was just fine. One customer I moved his gauge sensor, did not charge him and I was a miracle worker, the car never ran better. Really I put the sensor in a place where the water was cooler and did not do a thing to change the temp.

      Hoses and clamps

      I am a big fan of constant pressure band clamps instead of cheap universal hose clamps, they work better, have better more consistent clamping force. There are lots of cool silicone hoses that are really neat, somehow I generally end up fabricating some stainless tube with some rubber clamps on race cars and OEM high quality hoses for street cars. Tip if you’re looking to clean up your heater hoses Vega hoses have a nice 90 degree bend molded in and add for a clean look on most cars. Heat shrink tube works well as a clamp too but it is one time use. Another tip borrow or buy a radiator pressure tester and check for leaks, it can save you embarrassment especially if you are working on a race car. If you have a big budget use AN -20 hose, they rarely fail under extreme pressure.

      Radiator Caps

      Street cars run about 8-18 lb radiator cap, most race cars I have worked with have a 30 lb or higher.. At sea level water boils at 212 degrees. Every PSI of pressure in the system increases the boiling point by about 3 degrees so a 10 lb cap will increase the boiling point by 30 degrees. Now on street cars I run a 16 lb cap and expansion tank. I use a 30 lb cap in most race cars and pre pressurize the systems.

      Should I use an oil cooler?

      Yes if you can and a water to oil heat exchanger is the best. In working with the top engine builders in the world the advice I have heard over and over is the better you can control oil and coolant temps and make the temperature consistent in the block the better off you will be for long life and high performance. If you watch a NASCAR race on sunday you will notice all of these carts by the cars. These carts are preheating the oil and topping off the batteries. Why? They want the engine pre heated so it is ready to go and all the parts are the same temperature. Many dry sump systems can hold up to 5 gallons of oil? Oil cooling is extremely important in high horsepower endurance engines.

      Electrolysis

      This could be a story on its own. Without going into a chemistry lesson basically the water running through the cooling system can generate current, if the radiator and engine are not grounded that current can eat or corrode a radiator. Make sure the engine and radiator are both grounded to the car and the problem is solved. In some exotic cars they actually have a Zinc anode that will sacrifice its self-first instead of the radiator or Aluminum block.




    Advertise on Pro-Touring.com