Enter your username:
Do you want to login or register?
  • Forgot your password?

    Login / Register




    Results 1 to 10 of 10
    1. #1
      Join Date
      Mar 2008
      Location
      Chicago suburbs
      Posts
      667
      Country Flag: United States

      Weldcraft Refused

      I have some cast aluminum American Racing TTO wheels, 17X8. A few years ago I had the rears widened to 17X9 by Weldcraft. I was really happy with the work they did and have gone through a set of tires on those wheels. Yesterday I bought some new tires and the local (national chain) tire shop refused to service my rears because they were welded. This shop has been great to deal with otherwise. I had to convince another shop to mount them instead but even they were hesitant. So this got me thinking and searching on the internet- are these wheels safe?

      I am very familiar with similar steel welds, and I know that a steel butt weld with decent wall thickness has absolutely no strength issues. What about welding cast aluminum though?



    2. #2
      Join Date
      Apr 2012
      Location
      Woodstock, IL
      Posts
      2,410
      Country Flag: United States

      Weldcraft Refused

      Our tire shops have never questioned Weldcraft-widened wheels. Most of the time they're impressed with how well they balance out.

      We've run widened cast wheels on our Tempest for years... They added 3" to the back spacing to a 12.5 with 335 tires.
      No problem. They know what they're doing over there and have a ton of experience.

      -Dale
      SchwartzPerformance
      The leader in bolt-in muscle car chassis
      SchwartzPerformance.com | GMachineChassis.com | Facebook | Twitter | Instagram

      Dealer for: Forgeline, RideTech, Tremec, American Powertrain, Silver Sport Transmissions, GM Performance Parts, RECARO, Cerullo Seats, TMI Products, Vintage Air, Baer Brakes, Wilwood, BeCool, AFCO, Tanks Inc, Holley / Hooker, Ultimate Headers, Rick's Tanks, Moser Engineering, Currie, TechAFX, Stainless Works, II Much Fabrication, and many more

    3. #3
      Join Date
      Dec 2006
      Location
      Out of the Burbs of Detroit to SoCal, then onto my ancestral homeland, the woods of Cascadia
      Posts
      1,753
      Country Flag: United States
      It's easy for someone with limited knowledge to say no. These same guys believe if it wasn't made in a factory, it can't be safe. These guys will spend the rest of their life busting tires, because they have never been taught to think
      Greg Fast
      (yes, the last name is spelled correctly)

      1970 Camaro RS Clone
      1984 el Camino
      1973 MGB vintage E/Prod race car
      (Soon to be an SCCA H/Prod limited prep)

    4. #4
      Join Date
      Jan 2014
      Location
      Seattle WA
      Posts
      288
      Country Flag: United States
      Has nothing to do with not thinking. The insurance on the shop I ran not so long ago for a major tire brand would not allow it. Its about limiting exposure to liability in today litigious society. If that means turning away a modified wheel, that's what they will do. That insignificant amount they would have made to mount and balance is no loss when you look at the big picture.
      1967 El Camino 408ci LSx....and the build begins!
      1967 Turbocharged 408ci LSx Chevelle - 1012 rwhp, 959 rwtq 67 Chevelle
      2009 Supercharged Silverado - On the Dyno

    5. #5
      Join Date
      Mar 2008
      Location
      Chicago suburbs
      Posts
      667
      Country Flag: United States
      Thanks guys- I love that Tempest by the way

      I figured that it was probably a liability thing, but did they start refusing to work on them due to actual failures? According to the sales guy "We have seen too many of them fail" I'm hoping that the failures were improper welds.

      Some policies tire shops have drive me nuts, like not mounting "old" tires, etc. but if my wheels truly are unsafe I'll buy another set.

    6. #6
      Join Date
      Apr 2014
      Location
      South Central MN
      Posts
      9
      Country Flag: United States
      I've worked for a national chain tire store and I wouldn't worry about them not wanting to mount them. It is all about the liability of a modified part on your car. A guy at work mentioned to me Walmart wouldn't mount used tires on his truck. They put them on the rims but he had to put them on himself in the parking lot.

      I looked on Weldcrafts page about modifying wheels. I've been a certified welder for 20 years and my personal opinion it looks like they know what they are doing. If they feel the load range of the wheels aren't compromised I wouldn't worry about it. If they had liability concerns themselves they wouldn't be modifying wheels for customers.

      Dennis

    7. #7
      Join Date
      Aug 2012
      Location
      Peoria, AZ
      Posts
      1,758
      Country Flag: United States
      You should have seen the waiver I had to sign just to get Discount Tire to mount 275/45/17 Falkens on (4) 17x9.5 rims to go on my Monte.

      "You know those wheels and tires won't fit right?"
      "We won't take these back if they are mounted and won't fit after you take them home"
      "Sure, just sign right here and we'll mount those right up for you"

      I don't have any experience with widened wheels, but I have plenty of experience with Corporate America and what they do to limit their liability...which this sounds like a case of.
      Lance
      1985 Monte Carlo SS Street Car

    8. #8
      Join Date
      Dec 2004
      Location
      HILLBILLY HOLLYWOOD, TENNESSEE!!!
      Posts
      2,044
      As stated earlier this is a liability issue.

      BMW cannot certify a late model used BMW unless it has the factory specified "Run Flat" tires on the car. The local BMW dealer (Sonic) makes a big deal about this on a trade and offers significantly less money for a BMW that does not have "Run Flats" as they must install a new set of "Run Flats" on a trade to be able to "Certify" the car according to BMW.

      Run Flats SUCK! They ride rough and typically have a treadwear rating less than 200. BMW really thinks that I am going to pay over $1,000 to replace the Run Flats on a 3 Series BMW when I can buy 600 Treadwear Michelin's for about $600? I don't think so!

      What about a spare tire? Buy some Slime or a donut sparre for the car and go on!

      Aren't Lawyers wonderful???
      Mike

      Remember, "Drive Fast, Turn Heads, Break Hearts!"

      www.musclecardeals.com

    9. #9
      Join Date
      Dec 2008
      Location
      Detroit
      Posts
      2,665
      Country Flag: United States
      I've had wheels repaired by Weldcraft and I know people that have had factory wheels widened by them to run drag radials without a problem. I wouldn't see it as a concern, just keepo using the same shop for mounts.
      Big dreams, small pockets....

      Chris--
      '72 Cutlass S LSA/T56 Magnum
      Bowler Performance, Forgeline, Speedtech, ATS, Speartech, KORE3, Ridetech coilovers

      Project Motor City Madness

    10. #10
      Join Date
      May 2004
      Location
      Dallas, TX
      Posts
      864
      Country Flag: United States
      I have been running my Weldcraft narrowed fronts for almost 8 yrs with no problems whatsoever.




    Advertise on Pro-Touring.com