Enter your username:
Do you want to login or register?
  • Forgot your password?

    Login / Register




    Results 1 to 5 of 5
    1. #1
      Join Date
      Feb 2005
      Location
      Waterloo, Ia
      Posts
      1,408

      Cast vs Forged wheels

      Just wondering what the big differences are in performance with cast vs forged wheels. The forged look is obvious and the price is usually much higher. Even compared to an American made cast wheel like a Billet Specialty Mag-G.

      What are the distinct performance advantages in forged wheels over cast and would the average street driver, canyon carver and mild auto-X enthusiast honestly be able to tell? Lest assume the car is well built, and solid. Its already set up to handle well with a complete SC&C stage II chassis, Kore3 Z51 brakes and the tires are the exacts same size, brand, and model. The wheels are the exact same size and backspacing. We are just swapping wheels cast to forged. Would a driver be able to tell the difference with an A-B-A type of testing?

      -Nick
      -1967 GTO I drive and race
      -Build threads:
      -http://forums.maxperformanceinc.com/forums/showthread.php?t=615847&page=23
      -https://www.pro-touring.com/showthre...project-thread



    2. #2
      Join Date
      Apr 2012
      Location
      Woodstock, IL
      Posts
      2,410
      Country Flag: United States

      Cast vs Forged wheels

      You likely won't be able to tell the difference. Cast wheels aren't as strong as forged so they tend to have more material to compensate. The manufacturing process is the main reason why they are more expensive. It's very cheap to cast anything.
      One of the benefits to 3 piece wheels is that you can replace an outer shell if it scrapes a curb or something for not much cash. There are companies that'll cut apart your wheel and fix a rim on a cast wheel but you have to send it out. I've replaced rim shells myself and it's pretty easy.

      In ANY build, there will always be refinements, improvement, and maybe even big changes along the way.
      If you can't afford a Forgeline, then don't buy one. Get your feet wet in the racing scene and when you can afford lighter wheels, then do it at that time if you feel the need.

      -Dale
      SchwartzPerformance
      The leader in bolt-in muscle car chassis
      SchwartzPerformance.com | GMachineChassis.com | Facebook | Twitter | Instagram

      Dealer for: Forgeline, RideTech, Tremec, American Powertrain, Silver Sport Transmissions, GM Performance Parts, RECARO, Cerullo Seats, TMI Products, Vintage Air, Baer Brakes, Wilwood, BeCool, AFCO, Tanks Inc, Holley / Hooker, Ultimate Headers, Rick's Tanks, Moser Engineering, Currie, TechAFX, Stainless Works, II Much Fabrication, and many more

    3. #3
      Join Date
      Sep 2012
      Location
      Dayton, Ohio
      Posts
      1,423
      Country Flag: United States
      I would add that not all forged wheels are equal, even within a manufacturer's own lineup. It just depends on for what and for whom they were engineered. Style, weight, strength, and deflection stiffness are all desired attributes, but every wheel design involves some tradeoffs.

      From my perspective, the advantages of a custom forged wheel are:
      1. Because the forged aluminum is more dense, less porous, and has a stronger grain structure, a forged wheel should always offer a better combination of weight/strength/stiffness tradeoffs. The exact combination of those tradeoffs will vary, depending on the engineering of the specific wheel. But holding weight constant, it will be stronger and stiffer. Or holding deflection stiffness constant, it will be stronger and lighter.
      2. Because a forged wheel is typically custom made-to-order (at least within our business model at Forgeline), the fitment specs are specific to the customer's vehicle. So the offsets and widths are perfect. You don't need spacers. You're not sticking too far inboard or outboard. You shouldn't have rubbing. Yes, it is expensive to make wheels one at a time with each wheel being different from the next, but this allows no compromises. Cast wheels tend to be one size fits all, so the fitment is seldom perfect for anybody. (This is especially an issue in the pro-touring market, where so many customers have very unique combinations of body/axle/brakes/hubs. Finding a cast wheel that fits "right" isn't always possible. A custom wheel can be built to match any crazy combination of components.)
      3. Custom wheels offer custom finish options. This is especially true on a three piece wheel, since you can opt for different finishes on the center, outer, and inner. And you usually have options on the assembly hardware too. When you consider how much money, time, and effort people invest in the rest of their vehicles, I think that seems only logical that they would want their own custom finish combination on the wheels too. After all, wheels can make or break the look of any vehicle.
      4. As Dale noted, a three piece wheel also offers additional flexibility down the road. If you bend an outer, it is pretty simple to replace. If you decide to try a different finish combination down the road, you can do that. If you need to replace inners and/or outers to accommodate an axle or fender change, that is possible.

      Whatever you decide, Dale is a great resource. He not only has lots of experience with fitting and ordering Forgeline wheels, but he also understands the rest of the build too. Thanks, Dale!
      Last edited by Forgeline Wheels; 04-16-2014 at 10:10 AM.
      Mark Schetter
      Forgeline Motorsports, LLC
      Dayton, Ohio
      1-800-886-0093 x12
      [email protected]
      www.forgeline.com





      Join Our Newsletter Mailing List

    4. #4
      Join Date
      Jul 2012
      Location
      Iowa
      Posts
      399
      Country Flag: United States
      Hey Nick I sent you a PM.
      Miles Boyer
      The car hobby is dangerous,if the speed doesn't kill you, the cost of parts will.
      91 V8 S10
      88 Cutlass Pro-Tour
      97 Chevy lifted Z-71
      96 Corvette

    5. #5
      Join Date
      Jan 2013
      Location
      Bridgewater, NJ
      Posts
      117
      Country Flag: United States
      As a manufacturer of semi forged wheels, I fully agree with both Dale and Mark's comments. We don't compete directly with Forgeline or any other forged wheel manufacturer, but they have earned our respect on all levels.

      For our customers, there needs to be a right mix of price, strength, design and fitment; but we are dealing with much lower budget cars for the most part. In the past, I had a few customers contact me with big budgets and lofty goals and suggested they contact the big dogs of the forged wheel world for their needs.

      There is a correlation between wheel weight and performance - a lighter wheel is more efficient in terms of accelerating, decelerating, turning, and control (by the dampers) than a heavier wheel. This also applies to tires as their weights can vary in the same size. I have a few published articles where cars were tested with different wheel diameters (but the same section width) and at a certain point, the car slowed down in acceleration noticeably due to weight, handled worse (weight and too small sidewall), and the ride suffered (weight and sidewall). I have a Chumpcar racer who moved from a 34lb 17" x 8" wheel to our 20lb 17" x 9.5" wheels (with the same tires) and the car responded by picking up 3 seconds a lap at his home track - not to mention a seat of the pants acceleration boost (he said it was about 25hp) and much better suspension control. 14lbs is an extreme case, but even a 6lb decrease per wheel - which may be the difference between a heavy OEM cast wheel and a forged wheel in the same size; would work in a similar fashion, just at a lower magnitude.
      Paul Huryk
      President CTW Motorsports
      1989 GTA - Global West Suspension, Wilwood Brakes, CTW Motorsports wheels, Full Magnaflow exhaust
      1984 Camaro - Global West Suspension, Baer brakes, CTW Motorsports wheels, Mild 350 with nitrous



      http://www.ctw-motorsports.com




    Advertise on Pro-Touring.com