Enter your username:
Do you want to login or register?
  • Forgot your password?

    Login / Register




    Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 LastLast
    Results 1 to 20 of 45

    Hybrid View

    1. #1
      Join Date
      Apr 2006
      Location
      Huntington Beach, CA
      Posts
      2,420
      Country Flag: United States

      New Camaro sure is impractical.

      So I finally got around to driving one of the new Camaros this past weekend. I rented a loaded 6 cylinder hard top model and drove it around for four days. As I haven’t had any real interest in purchasing the car I haven’t read any reviews on it or followed it so I had no expectations other than the exterior looks have grown on me and it looks cool.

      First, the cool stuff I liked about the car:
      - As mentioned I really like the exterior styling. Great looking car.
      - Some of the interior materials are nice such as the seats and steering wheel (my car was leather)
      - Heads up display
      - Sport mode for the transmission and paddle shifters on the wheel (though shift from first to second was a bit sluggish when using the paddle shifters)
      - V6 power was impressive. Car was able to get up and scoot very well.
      - Lay out of controls was pretty intuitive for a long time GM driver and easy to use

      Ok the stuff that I didn’t like
      - I still remember reviewers blasting the 4th gen Camaro for poor visibility and the visibility in this car blew my freeking mind!!! I mean that absolute most terrible visibility out of any car I have ever been in, in my life. I can handle poor rear window visibility and even some big blind spots in the rear quarter area. However, the dash and door lines are so high that even forward and sideways visibility sucked. I got used to it and could easily drive the car around but I didn’t ever LIKE it. I still can’t believe they designed it to be this bad.
      - Headroom totally sucked! I’m really hoping that because the car I drove had the sun roof that the normal coupe has an extra inch or two of headroom. I had to tilt the seat to a ridiculous angle to prevent my head from hitting the ceiling. I also found it really weird that if I lowered my head so that my hair wasn’t rubbing all over the ceiling then my eyes were low enough that the bottom of the heads up display began to cut off (though upon reflection maybe that can be adjusted?). My dad has a late model mustang and he gave me a ride at one point over the weekend to my car and I could sit normally in the seat and have loads of room to spare above my head.
      - WHAT the hell was GM thinking in the trunk design? I actually laughed out loud when my wife opened the truck to put our bags in. The trunk itself is plenty roomy, you just can’t get your bags in there lol. The lid is already somewhat small which given the body lines I agreed with but the tail light parts protruded into the trunk too.

      Just like the fourth Gen Camaro I think you have to really want a Camaro to buy one of these. For the more casual driver any performance advantage is not going to offset some of the crazy limitations the car has that the Mustang doesn’t.

      Final note. Nobody had reset the average MPG tracker on the computer (based on the average mpg not moving my whole 4 days and both trip meters still equaling the odometer). In 7,600 miles the 6 cyl car has averaged 22.2 mpg.



      Anyhow, just thought I’d share the experience with my car friends.
      Please Subscribe to the AutoXandTrack YouTube Channel

      Autocross and track blog about running autocross and track events with pro touring cars


    2. #2
      Join Date
      Dec 2010
      Posts
      708
      It seems par for the course: They made "improvements," but didn't think about much from a logical perspective. I had similar thoughts when testing the new 370z a couple years ago. You couldn't see a damn thing out of it while driving, and the visual changes they'd made were just ugly--it was like they'd gone for the look of a BMW Z4 and failed. The previous model (350z) was better (I had one, and had lots of issues with it as well...)--I imagine many Camarophiles have been saying the same thing, large-size Geo Storm comments notwithstanding.

    3. #3
      Join Date
      Jun 2009
      Location
      Central FL
      Posts
      1,231
      I'm glad they made another, but I'm not happy with it. The ass end is too large for my tastes, I really don't like the dash, and the windows are tiny.

      That said, the leather interior is really nice, and the power plant will become cheaper and eventually enter my car.
      Dan
      1968 Camaro v2
      LS6 :: Viper T56 :: C5 Brakes :: Hotchkis Suspension


    4. #4
      Join Date
      Feb 2008
      Location
      Orange County, CA
      Posts
      172
      Chad,

      I hear you on the head room thing......I am tall, but fit in just about everything I've sat in. I tried to test drive a hard top SS model and my head was touching the headliner with the seat all the way down and angled way back.......

      Obvious deal breaker - I didn't even try to drive it.
      Mike F.


    5. #5
      Join Date
      Nov 2010
      Posts
      1,387
      Country Flag: United States
      hahhahah I understand. I am 6'7 and have the 2ss manual. Even though i understand ur complaints i love it. It fits fine. especially with how adjustable the front seat is.
      But I also like to recline my chair, so maybe thats the difference. However the trunk is terrible lol and no visibility out the rear window.
      68 Camaro RS twin turbo
      https://www.pro-touring.com/threads/...d-Intent-V-2-0

      1993 Toyota Supra 6768 Built Single Turbo


      Slow Lifted Jeep No TURBO :(

      Randal F

    6. #6
      Join Date
      Jul 2008
      Location
      Dallas, TX
      Posts
      260
      Quote Originally Posted by rfalker1 View Post
      hahhahah I understand. I am 6'7 and have the 2ss manual. Even though i understand ur complaints i love it. It fits fine. especially with how adjustable the front seat is.
      But I also like to recline my chair, so maybe thats the difference. However the trunk is terrible lol and no visibility out the rear window.
      I don't see how... I'm 6'6" and I could not fit in a 5th gen with a sun roof. Not sure how much not having a sun roof would buy, but I don't see it being enough to make me not have to lean so far back I can't see. The car feels bigger than my Chevelle on the outside, Miata-small on the inside. Can you even find a SS without a sunroof? If it like most cars I've seen, the upgraded models always seem to come with sunroofs.

      It's funny though, I do fit ok in a 4th gen, C5 and C6 'vette and the newer mustangs.
      '69 Chevelle - LQ4/T56
      '71 GMC SWB Fleetside - LM7/AR5

    7. #7
      Join Date
      Jan 2010
      Location
      Somewhere out there
      Posts
      283
      Country Flag: United States
      I'm a HUGE fan of the 2012 Bumblebee edition.
      The previous Bumblebee was gayer then a bag of d**ks, but this one is wicked.
      http://www.flickr.com/photos/3303109...n/photostream/

    8. #8
      Join Date
      Jul 2001
      Location
      Detroit, Michigan
      Posts
      6,854
      Country Flag: United States
      I think when history looks back people will refer to the 5th gen Camaro as the "Fat Boy" Camaro.

      Chad you're analysis is spot on. Yes the car is absolutely beautiful in it's design but once you sit in it you descover it's limitations which are ultimately a consequence of the car's exterior theme. What also drives these limitations is the vehicle's Zeta architecture. The belt line on the car is high but the holden version has a higher roof. Design fought tooth and nail to get that roof as low as possible, I always felt it needed another inch at least and I don't think it would have hurt the car's looks too much. The interior has a cavernous feel to it (almost like riding in a tank). But still I like the car as a whole. Not a fan of the interior though...never have been.

      I will say that the non-sunroof car does have more headroom making it more enjoyable to drive. Last week I had to oppurtunity to drive my Uncle's 2011 Mustang GT for a few days because he needed to borrow my truck. I hate to admit this but the Mustang feels lighter, nimble, & more athletic.

      My hopes are the 6th gen car will go in this direction.
      Last edited by trapin; 02-22-2012 at 06:59 AM.
      1968 Pro-Touring Camaro LS1

      Project: Next Year
      - Start date; June '01
      - Completion; Sometime next year or the year after.....

    9. #9
      Join Date
      May 2011
      Location
      Central FL
      Posts
      216
      Quote Originally Posted by trapin View Post
      Design fought tooth and nail to get that roof as low as possible......
      There is a balance to be struck between design and engineering. In the end however, car sales have always done better when design wins out over bean counters and engineers. The Camaro continues to out sell the Mustang and Challenger because of its winning design IMHO.
      Last edited by trapin; 02-22-2012 at 06:58 AM.
      - David
      1967 Camaro - In remembrance of my friend Scott

    10. #10
      Join Date
      Mar 2006
      Location
      Sunny Florida on the Suncoast
      Posts
      1,060
      Country Flag: United States
      The high body sides is the way the manufactures are getting through the newest side impact standards. I bet the next generation Mustangs may suffer with the same high sides and mail slot windows like the Camaro and Challanger have. If you really want to see how tall the 5th Gen Camaro really is, park it next to a 4th gen f-body and the new Camaro is massive. I love the 5th Gen Camaro for its handling, styling, and power......now the weight is rediculous (it is a fat pig!) and the head room is too tight (if your over 6ft don't even consider a sunroof). I hated the button shifter on the steering wheel (GM if your going to do paddle shifters then do PADDLE SHIFTERS!!!). I think that GM did an OK job with the Camaro, and that Ford did a slightly better Mustang with the S197 but take the best of both and make an awesome sports coupe. I would still like to have a new Camaro but I would not give up my Monte Carlo, Malibu, or even my C10 truck for it.
      Stay in it till you see God....then lift

      Where patience fails, force prevails

      "When you're born, you get a ticket to the freak show. When you're born in America, you get a front-row seat." G. Carlin

      Stapp's Ironical Paradox...... "The universal aptitude for ineptitude makes any human accomplishment an incredible miracle."

    11. #11
      Join Date
      Mar 2009
      Location
      SoCal
      Posts
      1,240
      Country Flag: United States
      Quote Originally Posted by 406 Q-ship View Post
      The high body sides is the way the manufactures are getting through the newest side impact standards. I bet the next generation Mustangs may suffer with the same high sides and mail slot windows like the Camaro and Challanger have. If you really want to see how tall the 5th Gen Camaro really is, park it next to a 4th gen f-body and the new Camaro is massive. I love the 5th Gen Camaro for its handling, styling, and power......now the weight is rediculous (it is a fat pig!) and the head room is too tight (if your over 6ft don't even consider a sunroof). I hated the button shifter on the steering wheel (GM if your going to do paddle shifters then do PADDLE SHIFTERS!!!). I think that GM did an OK job with the Camaro, and that Ford did a slightly better Mustang with the S197 but take the best of both and make an awesome sports coupe. I would still like to have a new Camaro but I would not give up my Monte Carlo, Malibu, or even my C10 truck for it.
      Only slightly? I was really excited when the 5th gen came out, but I now actively hate the car from the needless and disjointed "Corvette spice" styling cues to the 11/10's scale to the horrible driver accommodations. The S197 on the other hand, I've loved since it came out and it has more than lived up to it's looks. I'm afraid if you take the best of both cars you just end up with another Mustang, just with a transmission that wouldn't break (and probably still with the live axle.)

      Is anyone else bothered by the weird hard plastic insert in the 5th gen's doors? For perspective, you have an owner of a 1979 Trans Am complaining about the feeling of interior materials in a modern car.
      Brett H.

      1979 Pontiac Firebird Trans Am
      1991 Mazda Miata
      2005 Ford Mustang GT

      1987 Ford Mustang GT - Sold 06-29-2014
      1988 Oldsmobile Cutlass Ciera - RIP 9-17-2011
      1992 Chevrolet Corvette - Sold 10-12-2017

    12. #12
      Join Date
      Mar 2006
      Location
      Sunny Florida on the Suncoast
      Posts
      1,060
      Country Flag: United States
      Quote Originally Posted by 79-TA View Post
      Only slightly? I was really excited when the 5th gen came out, but I now actively hate the car from the needless and disjointed "Corvette spice" styling cues to the 11/10's scale to the horrible driver accommodations. The S197 on the other hand, I've loved since it came out and it has more than lived up to it's looks. I'm afraid if you take the best of both cars you just end up with another Mustang, just with a transmission that wouldn't break (and probably still with the live axle.)

      Is anyone else bothered by the weird hard plastic insert in the 5th gen's doors? For perspective, you have an owner of a 1979 Trans Am complaining about the feeling of interior materials in a modern car.
      When I was saying combine the best of the Mustang and Camaro. I would like the Body looks of the 2005-2009 Mustang along with its weight but the Camaro's driveline and suspension. I am sorry but until Ford came out with the 5.0 in 2011 the GT Mustang was a joke, I have never liked any of the Mod Motor Fords. The LS gets it done better for cheaper. Transmission wise the Mustang and Camaro are alike whether it is the TKO's in the Stang (or the T56 in the 2011 up) and the T56 the Camaro uses. I am sorry but for a great handling street car the independent suspension in the rear of the Camaro is better, on a nice smooth race track the Mustang does very well (even does OK in the rough but not as good as the Camaro). I think both cars have their faults and I would love to have either one, just find a way to loose 400 lbs off the Camaro and then it is Camaro all the way for me. 3800 lbs and heavy a$$ 20 inch wheels for a Pony Car, what was GM thinking?
      Stay in it till you see God....then lift

      Where patience fails, force prevails

      "When you're born, you get a ticket to the freak show. When you're born in America, you get a front-row seat." G. Carlin

      Stapp's Ironical Paradox...... "The universal aptitude for ineptitude makes any human accomplishment an incredible miracle."

    13. #13
      Join Date
      Nov 2010
      Location
      Novi Mi
      Posts
      143
      Country Flag: United States
      The problem I see with the 5th gen camaro, is it uses the same platform as a pontiac g8. If your building a sports car, why use the same platform as a sedan for a coupe. I know the cts is done that way, and I hate the butt end of those. I hope gm cleans up a little bit with the next generations of their models in the next few years. I still haven't owned a foreign car, and I want to keep it that way.

    14. #14
      Join Date
      Aug 2004
      Location
      Ontario, Canada
      Posts
      2,314
      Country Flag: Canada
      Quote Originally Posted by olason View Post
      The problem I see with the 5th gen camaro, is it uses the same platform as a pontiac g8. If your building a sports car, why use the same platform as a sedan for a coupe.
      Cost.
      The very same reason F-bodies and X-bodies shared platforms for the first two generations. Without those cost savings the current Camaro would never have made it to the dealers show room.

      Ken
      If there is a hard way to do something, I'll find it!
      My other car is a Vega.

    15. #15
      Join Date
      Sep 2007
      Posts
      460
      The 2010 Camaro is probably the first car in history where customizers will RAISE the roof to improve it.

    16. #16
      Join Date
      Sep 2010
      Posts
      660
      Country Flag: United States
      Nice personal review. Thanks

    17. #17
      Join Date
      Jan 2006
      Location
      Cornettsville, ky
      Posts
      899
      Country Flag: United States
      in all fairness ive only thought the 2nd gens where even decently comfortable

    18. #18
      Join Date
      Jun 2001
      Location
      Orlando, FL
      Posts
      10,604
      Country Flag: United States
      I used to describe my long-gone 2001 Z28 as big on the outside and small on the inside.
      ​John Parsons

      UnRivaled Rides -- Modern upgrades for your ride.

      UnRivaled Rides recent project -- LS9-powered 69 Camaro

    19. #19
      Join Date
      Aug 2005
      Location
      Hamilton, NJ
      Posts
      4,319
      Country Flag: United States
      how can a car that big have useless back seats?
      Scott from NJ.

      Vent Windows Forever! ...

      Feather-light suspension, Konis just couldn't hold
      I'm so glad I took a look inside your showroom doors

    20. #20
      Join Date
      Aug 2004
      Location
      Holmes Hollow, Ontario Canada
      Posts
      991
      Tony, you said 6th gen. That's awesome. What I would love to see on the 5th gen (don't laugh) is t-roofs.
      Olason, as far as platform is concerned it doesn't mean that they can just switch bodies. Besides, have you driven a G8? My buddy has the GT. It will put down high 13s in stock form, handles nicely, and fits like a glove. I love that car - nothing wrong with the platform.
      ____________________________________________
      Scott

    Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 LastLast



    Advertise on Pro-Touring.com