Results 41 to 44 of 44
Thread: Fatman Spindles
Threaded View
-
01-03-2008 #1
Registered User
- Join Date
- Jan 2008
- Posts
- 10
differences in UCA designs
************ Message from Moderator David Pozzi
This thread was originally part of the A arm discussion (Sticky) thread. I have moved all the off-topic posts here. While the discussion got rather unpleasant, there is some good tech and things to think about. - It just didn't belong in the other thread.
I have been doing some research into UCA designs, and would offer a few points. I agree with Matt at Lateral Dynamics that MIG versus TIG welding is more a matter of style than strength. However, since the TIG process is inherently a hands on process, where automated MIG welding is often used to reduce costs, quality control is often better with TIG. That is assuming that the welder is capable and caring!
Moog introduced offset upper control arm shafts long ago since these cars subframes are often out of whack enough that alignment can be difficult. With an offset shaft design, a 3/16" difference is available thru the offset that lets you change the effective length of the UCA a total of 3/8". That really helps get positive camber numbers when the frame is sagged thru use. The better MFG use these, often in a billet steel CNC machined versions because the original MOOG ones are getting hard to get. Matter of fact, those retaining stock stamped arms would often benefit by using these shafts.
Urethane bushings have become a standard for higher performance thru less compliance, but opinions vary as to their effect on ride harshness. Fresh rubber bushings do pretty good, but normal wear needs repair.
Some MFG also alter the position and angle of the upper ball joint. Since lowering these cars is common, the ball joint angles can suffer getting to their limits, and normal caster is reduced by any rake that results. By setting the upper BJ back, more caster is preset, and good alignment can result without bizarre shim stacks. I run 3 degrees positive caster for a real good in the groove feel at speed.
Some guys claim to improve camber action with their arms, but that seems like marketing, not engineering. The shape of the tube has nothing to do with geometry. It's the position of the pivots that creates the action of the control arms and spindles. That's why the UCA relocation technique and the taller improved camber dropped spindles work.
These are questions that will be worth asking when you are shopping. If they can't answer or seem confused, be wary.Last edited by David Pozzi; 02-08-2008 at 09:39 AM.
-





Reply With Quote



