PDA

View Full Version : Comparison of Turbo motor Vs. N/A motor info!



nitrorocket
06-30-2006, 10:06 AM
I though I would list my experience with my turbo engine compared to my previous motor, pro’s and con’s. I figured some might take this info as good knowledge for there own future projects. It is info you don’t see first hand anywhere and stuff a lot of people don’t realize.

Old motor:

- 427” Tall deck dart block SBC
-4” stroke
-6.125” rods
-Solid roller .690 lift cam, 265 @.050
-10.5:1 compression
-18 degree Dart heads with 2.15/1.625” valves
-1.7:1 shaft rockers
-1.625” valve springs with 750 lb. open pressure!
-Custom single plane “053” Nascar intake
-Accel Gen 7 fuel injection & 83 lb./hr injectors
-Approx. 650 hp at 7000 rpm.

This motor costs approximately $20,000 to duplicate. It was built to be a “Street” driver motor. The engine was driven a about 3000 total miles over the few years I had it along with a few drag strip passes. It sounded wicked and had gobs of power for a N/A motor. The fuel injection was a nice feature for startup drivability and consistency, but added huge cost to the engine.

Positives of the motor were the sound; it sounded awesome, had a real nice rumble and had about a 1000 rpm idle. The motor would start right up at the turn of the key at any temp, never had to touch the gas. The motor was also a simple standard SBC based motor that was very easy to work on.

Negatives were the cost, $20k is way too much money for a motor that is not for racing and gets street driven. Motors wear out, and to wear out a $20K engine by cruising back and forth to a car show did not make sense! The motor got very poor mileage. I was getting right about 10 mpg if I drove nice, if I went on beat runs, I could burn a half tank within 10 miles. The motor was also very high maintenance. Most people do not realize until you own one how much this can limit you and cost. I had to replace the valve springs, rocker bearings, and lifters every 1500 miles! At $900 in parts alone, this was not fun.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
New turbo motor:

-347” Aluminum block LS1
-Stock crank
-6.125” rods
-Hydraulic Roller .581 lift, 224 @ .050
-8:1 Compression
-Factory heads with porting
-Dual valve springs
-Stock intake
-Stock computer & 96lb/hr fuel injectors
-Makes about 1000 hp at 6000 rpm

Turbo setup:

-Twin 61 mm GT35 Ball bearing turbos
-1.75” stainless headers
-Twin Racegate Wastegates
-1 50mm Blow off valve
-1500 CFM air/air intercooler

I have half into this motor over what my 427 cost. This motor is actually a real “street” motor. I can drive cross-country back and forth until I run out of gas money! It idles at 800 rpm, can go on a cruise without attracting Police officers, and is quiet. I have driven the motor about 1500 miles along with a dyno pull and strip pass so far with good results.

Positives of the motor are the mileage. The setup is getting about 15-city mpg and should get about 20-mpg highway if I drive nice. The motor is quiet enough to finally hear my radio and talk with my family! Being that the moor is basically just a ls1 with turbos on it, it runs drives, starts, and does everything a regular ls1 does. That is REAL nice, I don’t have to worry about maintenance and getting stranded over some rare expensive race part failure. The power is more then a street car EVER needs.

Negatives are the complexity of the setup. On top of the simple little LS1, is a lot of plumbing. There are lines all over for oiling, cooling, and exhaust that were not easy to rout cleanly. The other negative is that I had to design and build the entire setup myself instead of buy parts off the shelf. This added a lot of time to the build. I had one turbo failure from a faulty turbo that resulted in the purchase of the two ball bearing turbos, that failure will not happen again. This may sound weird but another negative is the power. If you are not careful it can get out of hand real fast. With each ¼” of throttle pedal travel equaling about 100 hp, if you go over a bump in the road or slide in your seat and wiggle the gas pedal…. The tires will spin.


Conclusion…. Forced induction, whether it be turbo’s or a supercharger, is the BEST way to make reliable power. You can never have a motor with all the benefits without it. It is also much cheaper then a big horsepower N/A motor. That was a factor that made me go the F.I. route.

6'9"Witha69
06-30-2006, 10:44 AM
That is a nice Comparison. Thanks for the thoughts! All too often we all hear the big power numbers but fail to get a "full picture" of the diffences.

ProStreet R/T
06-30-2006, 11:22 AM
Turbos are definitely where it's at. You have a 1000hp motor that for all intensive purposes behaves like a mostly stock LS1, pretty hard to beat that.

What are the specs on your trubos? I've purposely stayed a little on the big side to avoid the instant throttle response. It's nice having a car that is super tame up till 3200 rpm, and from there on out it's all on you, and if you have the brass to hold it open lol.

Then again starting with a 488" 500hp motor allows a little slack here and there.

DJW32
06-30-2006, 11:30 AM
Great read! You run the stock computer? What software did you use to tune it? Do you have a 2 bar or 3 bar setup? What kind of muffler are you running? How big is the dp? I watched your dyno pull...The car sounded great

F70t/a
06-30-2006, 11:45 AM
Ditto:yum:

ACEFOOTER
06-30-2006, 01:11 PM
Cool post Nitro. Do you have issues with un-anticpated wheel spin during cornering with the twin turbo set up? Would a supercharged combo be less likely to create instant wheel spin than the turbos?

nitrorocket
06-30-2006, 01:21 PM
I think at this power level, no form of forced induction would be better for spinning the tires. I have to get off my lazy but and hook up my gear actuated boost settings. I can change the bost level based on what gear I am in! The wheel spin should be more controlable then.:hmm:

-Yes I run the stock pcm and tune with EFILIVE software.
-I run a 3 bar setup.
-I am running 3" Dynomax ultraflows (Made about 100 hp more then Flowmaster 3 chamber!!)
-I run 3" downpipes to the rear bumper.
-I had Turbonetics 60-1 HI-FI turbos P-trim with a .68 AR.
-I now run a set of Ball bearing PT-61's, P-trim with a .68 AR. These have the e-cover and a larger GT35 compressor wheel over the HI-FI turbos.

BADVELLE
06-30-2006, 02:14 PM
I think at this power level, no form of forced induction would be better for spinning the tires. I have to get off my lazy but and hook up my gear actuated boost settings. I can change the bost level based on what gear I am in! The wheel spin should be more controlable then.:hmm:

-Yes I run the stock pcm and tune with EFILIVE software.
-I run a 3 bar setup.
-I am running 3" Dynomax ultraflows (Made about 100 hp more then Flowmaster 3 chamber!!)
-I run 3" downpipes to the rear bumper.
-I had Turbonetics 60-1 HI-FI turbos P-trim with a .68 AR.
-I now run a set of Ball bearing PT-61's, P-trim with a .68 AR. These have the e-cover and a larger GT35 compressor wheel over the HI-FI turbos.

I would say that the most impressive thing about this new motor is the cost, half the cost of the other, plus that much HP, nice! Do you have any pic's of your 3-bar setup?

nitrorocket
06-30-2006, 02:24 PM
I would say that the most impressive thing about this new motor is the cost, half the cost of the other, plus that much HP, nice! Do you have any pic's of your 3-bar setup?

Of my motor??

https://static1.pt-content.com/images/noimg.gif

Old:

https://static1.pt-content.com/images/noimg.gif

RobM
06-30-2006, 02:49 PM
thats awesome man, i have recently crossed over to the dark side of lsx engines.... what are you running for a fuel system?

nitrorocket
06-30-2006, 03:00 PM
I run an A1000 Aeromotive pump and matching reg. No boost reference.

USAZR1
06-30-2006, 05:23 PM
Why not run a single turbo set-up? It would have been much simpler and a little cheaper. Probably wouldn't make 1K horsepower but that much is overkill for a street car,anyway.
Not a flame,just curious,because I've thought about boosting my SBC.